Former deputy national police commissioner Shadrack Sibiya’s bail hearing is finally close to conclusion, as the defence has now presented its closing arguments.

The Randburg Magistrates Court has been hearing Sibiya’s bail application for three weeks now, with the State opposing his release.

ALSO READ:

Rape accuser fears for her life in Sibiya bail objection

Shadrack Sibiya accused of threatening minor's family in bail affidavit

Sibiya accused in court of receiving money from 'Cat' Matlala, bail hearing continues

The 59-year-old is accused of raping an 18-year-old woman and sexually grooming a 16-year-old girl.

Delivering its closing arguments on Wednesday, the defence challenged the State’s claim that Sibiya could intimidate witnesses if released from custody.

Over the past three weeks, the State has presented several pieces of evidence in an attempt to demonstrate that Shadrack Sibiya could interfere with the case or intimidate witnesses if granted bail.

The evidence includes voice notes in which Sibiya allegedly threatens the father of the minor he is accused of sexually grooming.

The State also played recordings of Sibiya’s friends, whom it refers to as a cabal, discussing plans to meet the 18-year-old teenager he is accused of raping.

However, Sibiya’s lawyer, Estelle Killian, maintains that her client has no intention of intimidating anyone.

“He takes no responsibility for members and persons in the public that independently from him, express views on social media. He denies the existence of a cabal,” Killian said.

The two victims told the court in an affidavit that they fear their lives could be endangered if Sibiya is granted bail.

Sibiya has denied ever threatening to “wipe out” the family of the minor he’s accused of sexually grooming.

The court heard during his bail application that Sibiya allegedly threatened “Mr M”, who is a former close friend of his and the minor’s father.

Delivering its closing arguments on Wednesday, the defence refuted claims that Sibiya threatened potential witnesses.

Sibiya was arrested on 21 September after “Mr M” opened a case against him, accusing him of sexually grooming his 16-year-old daughter.

“Mr M” claims that three days before the arrest, Sibiya called him after learning that a case had been opened against him.

He alleges that during the call, Sibiya threatened to “wipe out” his entire family.

However, Sibiya’s lawyer, Estelle Killian, told Magistrate Hleziphi Mkhasibe that the allegation is false.

Magistrate Mkhasibe: “What is your understanding of ‘do you know it can take a minute to wipe you and your family’?”

Killian: “I don’t want to speculate and I am not the person that can put interpretation to words uttered between parties allegedly. My client has just passed me a note to remind the court that he never uttered those words. He denies that he uttered them, and that is what should be focused on. It’s not common course that that was said.”

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.