Lawyers for Human Rights (LHR) believes the government should not approach the Constitutional Court for a supervisory order following a landmark ruling that struck down key provisions of the Refugee Act.
Justice Minister Mmamoloko Kubayi stated that the state will seek guidance on implementing the judgment, arguing that clarity is needed to do so in a practical and sustainable way.
ALSO READ:
Home Affairs says proposed asylum seeker registration model, builds on digital systems in place
Home Affairs withdraws directive as asylum seeker applications overwhelm systems, says Schreiber
This follows a Constitutional Court ruling declaring that asylum seekers cannot be disqualified for paperwork and border-entry violations before being considered for legal asylum status.
The July ruling sparked confusion at Home Affairs offices, with hundreds of asylum seekers queuing for documentation while misinformation fuelled unrest and anti-immigrant protests in parts of Johannesburg and Durban.
The LHR's Law Clinic manager, Carol Lemekwana, disagreed with the government’s move: "I just think there's been oversight from home affairs in how they have provided the first advisory... Just taking into consideration the number of people that have been in the country and have not been able to access the system."
Lekwana argued that the government should have first sought legal advice on how to implement the court order.
“The court order was issued in July, and they only came back after so many months... in October... and without processes and procedures on how they are going to implement that order,” Lemekwana said.
Lekwana added that it remains unclear whether the government has formally filed papers seeking the supervisory order.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.