Powerful interests have a financial incentive to keep Johannesburg's infrastructure broken, with corruption and manipulated tenders contributing to a cycle in which public money is spent fixing problems that should not keep recurring, an organised crime analyst says.

Alex Goodwin, an analyst at the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organised Crime (GI-TOC), says the worse the city's infrastructure becomes, the more opportunities arise for those seeking to profit from repair contracts.

Speaking to 702's John Perlman about a report examining corruption in Johannesburg, Goodwin described a vicious cycle in which failing infrastructure creates further demand for tenders, potentially allowing powerful interests to benefit from the city's deterioration.

“It's a vicious cycle because obviously the worse things get, the more they need repairs,” Goodwin said.

“This is one of the key findings we had from the report: that there are powerful interests who want to keep Johannesburg broken because the more broken it is, the more money there is to be made from it.”

The findings form part of Time for Action: Corruption in Joburg, a report produced by the Centre for Development and Enterprise (CDE) as part of its Johannesburg Matters series, with research conducted by GI-TOC.

Related articles:

— CDE calls for full tender transparency to curb corruption in Johannesburg

— 'Joburglary' report calls for political parties to reform JMPD, create oversight board

Political interference, tender manipulation fuel Joburg’s service crisis

Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype

How corruption can keep Johannesburg broken

Goodwin said the criminal activity affecting Johannesburg is driven by a combination of smaller players and more serious groupings, although he cautioned against viewing it as a conventional mafia hierarchy.

“I think it's a combination of both,” he said. “Mainly, though, they're motivated by profit.”

The consequences for the city are severe, he said, with the report examining corruption in tender processes alongside criminal activity involving infrastructure theft, sabotage and building hijacking.

The interview also explored concerns about the city's Group Forensic and Investigation Services (GFIS), which had reportedly investigated more than 6,000 cases involving R35 billion in transactions at stake.

Goodwin described the unit as an example of the institutional challenges facing efforts to tackle corruption.

He said GFIS had been hampered by a lack of capacity and difficulties asserting its operational independence, which he described as crucial to ensuring investigators could pursue those they needed to investigate.

The report identifies institutional capture as one of the strands of the problem. Goodwin explained that this involves officials influencing tender processes while also undermining accountability systems and appointments to boards.

However, he cautioned against attributing all of Johannesburg's problems to criminal activity.

“There are a lot of great people in the council trying to remedy it,” he said, adding that other problems stem from “decades of underinvestment and mismanagement in other ways”.

Could tracking every municipal repair help expose corruption?

One of the proposed ways to tackle corruption is to make public procurement radically more transparent.

Goodwin highlighted the potential of public dashboards that allow residents to track municipal repairs and scrutinise the contractors and spending involved.

He said similar systems are used in cities around the world, allowing the public to follow the progress of infrastructure repairs.

“If a water main's broken, you can see what company won the tender, who they are, what kind of capital they've got, how far they are into the fixing process, how much money they have,” he said.

Goodwin argued that such a system could help Johannesburg by making information about municipal projects more accessible to residents.

“If there was total public scrutiny of what's happening on your road, regarding that repair, suddenly the big picture becomes visible, and there are more eyes on it,” he said.

“And the more eyes on it, the more it's exposed.”

Greater transparency would be one part of a broader effort to strengthen accountability, he said.

Goodwin also backed the need to give GFIS the resources required to do its job, while arguing that high-profile cases against powerful individuals involved in corruption could help demonstrate that criminal activity carries consequences.

“We can discipline low-level people, but maybe it's going to take some landmark cases to show that crime doesn't pay,” he said.

The CDE has outlined 10 priorities for action in its report. Goodwin said GI-TOC was also working on its own recommendations, which it planned to release after the election.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.