The City of Cape Town insists that it is making significant progress in delivering affordable housing; however, critics argue there is little to show for it nearly a decade after the landmark Tafelberg court battle began.
After the Constitutional Court ruled the province and the city had not done enough to address the legacy of apartheid spatial planning, the two administrations were ordered to file reports in the Western Cape High Court last Friday.
Cape Town's housing crisis spirals, as demand grows by more than 3,000 a month
In its report, the city stated it had released 14 sites, including six in the inner city, with the potential to deliver about 4,000 affordable housing units.
The City of Cape Town said another 39 sites were in the pipeline and pointed to completed projects in Maitland, Goodwood, and Bothasig.
However, GOOD party Secretary-General Brett Herron said the reports showed no affordable housing projects had been completed in the Cape Town CBD and surrounding areas since the litigation began in 2017.
Herron expressed disappointment over the lack of delivery: "The reports confirm that this litigation has dragged on since 2017, promise after promise of land releases and thousands of affordable homes to come sometime or perhaps never."
Mayco Member for Human Settlements Carl Pophaim said an obstacle for the city was funding.
"The report also sets out major challenges with a lack of national funding, which has dropped by 41% since 2017, with no project funding awarded in the last five years despite many qualifying developments in our city."
Housing activists Ndifuna Ukwazi have since called on the city to develop internal financial mechanisms for social housing.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.