Could changing the way the Road Accident Fund (RAF) is funded help bring down the price of petrol?
Maybe, but motorists shouldn't expect a free ride.
That's according to Wayne Duvenage, CEO of the Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (OUTA).
The fund is primarily funded by a levy included in the price of petrol, which reached record levels on Wednesday.
The Democratic Alliance (DA) argues that scrapping the RAF could ease the burden on motorists and commuters.
But speaking to 702's Bongani Bingwa, Duvenage said plans to replace or reduce the RAF fuel levy risked simply shifting the financial burden onto consumers.
"A hybrid model would mean less in the fuel levy, but it's got to come from somewhere. It doesn't come from nowhere. Eventually, we all pay."
The current levy, which Duvenage said was R2.25 a litre, has risen from just 47 cents in 2009, greater than the rate of inflation.
He said the problem was not necessarily how much money the RAF collected, but how it was spent.
"It's a problem how the funds are used, and the government keeps doing it wrong... Government has this knee-jerk reaction to extract more as opposed to fix the problem."
ALSO READ:
RAF unlikely to overcome R43-billion claims load, says board chair
More than half of open RAF claims are now older than 5 years, annual report reveals
No easy fix: Road Accident Fund pleads with Parliament over broken funding model
RAF wants more from motorists, but will more money fix the fund?
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
And what about the proposal of introducing an annual insurance payment?
Duvenage said it could leave motorists facing another substantial bill when renewing their vehicle licences.
"If you go for the third-party insurance, you pay that once a year. But if you pay it in the fuel levy, it's incremental every time you buy petrol. You can't escape it. So it really becomes a massive shock once a year..."
According to OUTA, years of poor management have left the RAF in serious financial trouble.
Duvenage said its salary bill has grown from around R500 million to R2.5 billion.
A more effective solution than simply raising more revenue would be to call in the country's experienced insurance professionals, he said.
"We've got good insurance businesses in this country. Go and get those people out of retirement or some of the experts there and get the systems right."
Duvenage reckons what's needed at the RAF is better leadership, proper oversight and experienced staff.
"Before you try and extract more money, fix the Road Accident Fund and how it's managed."
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.