Premier-RFG merger on the line

Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype

The Competition Commission is acting to revoke approval for the merger of the Premier Group (Premier FMCG) and the food group RFG Holdings (formerly Rhodes Food Group).

The Commission filed an application with the Competition Tribunal to have the deal overturned over what it says was failure to disclose the contemplated closure of the RFG’s fruit-canning facility in Tulbagh during the review of the merger.

The Tribunal had approved this major merger between Premier and RFG in March, subject to conditions that included employment protections.

"Before the merger was referred to the Tribunal, the merger parties stated that they did not contemplate closing nor disposing of any manufacturing facilities or production lines, or equipment after the merger", the CompCom said.

In July, four months after the merger was implemented, Premier informed the authority that it intended to close the Tulbagh fruit cannery.

RELATED: Premier Foods workers anxious about losses should factory close down

The Commission’s application follows its investigation of a complaint lodged by, among others, the South African Clothing and Textile Workers Union.

SACTWU said that that the planned shutdown of the cannery would result in retrenchments, which was in breach of the merger conditions.

The Commission makes the point that the facility is a significant regional employer, which puts more than 400 permanent and fixed-term jobs at risk, along with thousands of seasonal workers across the broader agricultural value chain.

Stephen Grootes discusses the implications of the move with attorney Nicolene Schoeman-Louw, MD of SchoemanLaw Inc.

Schoeman-Louw points out that approval from the Competition authorities is not "a proverbial trophy we keep", but a permission granted on the facts that are disclosed.

"So, the regulator is well within its rights where material facts were withheld to essentially revoke its permission. The Competition Act specifically makes provision for that."

However, Schoeman-Louw's feeling is that overturning the merger or "unscrambling the proverbial egg" is probably less likely than the imposition of an administrative penalty in this case.

"These penalties can be up to 10% of turnover, which I believe is a much more likely outcome, provided that these versions are tested, and most likely would be subject to an appeal."

Scroll up to the audio player to listen to the full conversation