South Africa's asylum system is facing fresh pressure after Home Affairs instructed refugee reception offices to receive anyone who reports in person and indicates that they want to apply for asylum, including people who entered the country unlawfully.

The instruction follows Constitutional Court findings that provisions of the Refugees Act dealing with people who enter the country irregularly or delay applying for asylum were invalid.

The Deputy Director General for Operations at Home Affairs, Thulani Mavuso, told 702 that the department could now face a significant increase in the number of people seeking to lodge asylum applications.

“We're going to be overwhelmed with the numbers,” Mavuso said.

Related articles:

— ConCourt ruling on Refugee Act could turn heat on illegal immigration debate: HSF

— Schreiber wants White Paper to have legislative effect by March 2027

Home Affairs clarifies new refugee reception rules

Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype

What has changed?

Under the new instruction, refugee reception offices must receive people who indicate that they want to apply for asylum and assist them with lodging an application.

This includes people who entered South Africa unlawfully, entered somewhere other than a port of entry, did not declare an intention to seek asylum at a port of entry, do not hold a visa or did not report to a refugee reception office within five days of entering the country.

Mavuso said the change stems from a 2023 Constitutional Court judgment involving an Ethiopian national who had been arrested for unlawful entry and residence in South Africa.

The man said he had been unable to visit a refugee reception office because the offices had been closed during the COVID-19 pandemic. After his arrest, he said he wanted to claim asylum because he feared persecution in his country of origin.

Mavuso said the court ultimately found that a person in such circumstances could not simply be prevented from claiming asylum.

A subsequent matter brought against the Home Affairs minister also dealt with provisions of the Refugees Act.

Mavuso said the invalidity of the provisions was not suspended, meaning it took effect when the judgment was delivered.

Previously, a person who had entered South Africa unlawfully would have had to explain why they had entered or remained in the country illegally before proceeding with an asylum application.

“What changes is that there's no longer a need for that good cause letter based on the judgment,” Mavuso said.

He said asylum seekers would instead provide the relevant reasons as part of their asylum application, which would then be assessed.

Home Affairs warns of pressure on the system

Mavuso said the change could create significant administrative pressure, particularly because South Africa cannot impose a quota preventing people from lodging asylum applications.

He said the department would have to consider working longer hours and increasing staffing at refugee reception offices.

There are currently five refugee reception offices in the country, according to Mavuso.

He said the department had already seen large numbers of people arriving at some offices.

But the concern goes beyond the number of applications.

Mavuso said people who know they are not in South Africa because they are seeking protection from persecution could potentially join the queue of genuine asylum seekers, creating administrative delays.

“We have what we refer to as country-of-origin status, where, for example, we look at the countries, and we know that in a country, for example, like Egypt, someone says, I'm from Egypt, I'm seeking asylum,” he said.

He explained that individual circumstances could nevertheless justify an asylum claim, even where the broader conditions in a particular country were considered stable.

Economic hardship, however, does not in itself qualify someone for asylum.

Mavuso said economic migration was prevalent in Southern Africa, but hunger was not a basis for an asylum claim under the current framework discussed in the interview.

Claims still have to be assessed

The change does not mean that everyone who applies for asylum will be granted protection.

Mavuso said asylum applications undergo an assessment process involving interviews and consideration of the circumstances of the individual.

Country profiles are also used to help determine whether claims are credible.

He said some genuine asylum seekers might not even have travel documents and that officials therefore had to conduct extensive interviews to establish the facts.

“The word that the person gives you ought to be at some point backed by tangible evidence that is credible for us to be able to grant that status,” Mavuso said.

He cited political persecution as one example of a circumstance that could support an asylum claim.

Mavuso said South Africa had a high rate of rejection of asylum applications from neighbouring Zimbabwe, which he attributed largely to economic migration.

However, he said there were also cases where people could provide evidence that they had been persecuted because of their political views.

First safe country principle

Another issue raised in the interview was why people who travel through several countries before reaching South Africa should be able to seek asylum here.

Mavuso said the first safe country principle was currently contained in the government's White Paper, while legislation was being developed.

He said Home Affairs had also conducted research into how the principle could be implemented.

Mavuso said the department was “quite determined to apply that”, arguing that someone seeking protection should generally seek it at the next available point rather than travelling through multiple countries before reaching South Africa.

He added that there could be compelling circumstances in individual cases.

Returning home can affect an asylum claim

Mavuso also addressed what happens when an asylum seeker returns to the country they claim they are fleeing.

He said a person could not claim protection from persecution in a country and then voluntarily return to that same country.

“The law says you cannot avail yourself back to the country that you claim is persecuting you,” Mavuso said.

He said returning to that country meant the person could lose their right to protection.

Mavuso was also asked how Home Affairs establishes whether asylum seekers have criminal records in their countries of origin.

He acknowledged that this could be difficult because, unlike applicants for certain other types of visas, asylum seekers are not necessarily able to provide police clearances from their countries of origin.

What happens when an asylum application is rejected?

If an asylum application is rejected, Mavuso said the applicant no longer has status in South Africa.

“They've got to then voluntarily leave the country, or you get deported,” he said.

The process therefore remains one in which applicants must ultimately establish that they qualify for protection.

The immediate change is that irregular entry or a failure to report to a refugee reception office within the required period can no longer, by itself, be used to prevent a person from presenting themselves and seeking to lodge an asylum application.

For Home Affairs, however, the change comes with a significant operational challenge: ensuring that genuine asylum seekers can access the system while dealing with the increased administrative burden that could follow.