Joe Sibanyoni has concluded his testimony at the Madlanga Commission, where questions were raised about a R30 million transfer from the Shosholoza savings club to his company, payments to club members and an unexplained R865,000 balance.

The evidence leader also sought to establish whether funds linked to Tshwane Metro Police Department contracts flowed into the club.

  1. 1. Sibanyoni acknowledged a 40% profit-sharing arrangement
    He said his share was linked to providing local content for Tengani Mining's business arrangement with King Civil. The commission questioned what substantive service he provided beyond his participation as a local partner.
  2. 2. He confirmed receiving payments and advancing R900,000
    Sibanyoni acknowledged payments into his company and in cash, as well as his R900,000 loan to the project. Questions remained about the timing of the payments and how the loan related to the profit-sharing arrangement.
  1. 3. The local-content arrangement was not supported by documentation presented in the questioning
    Sibanyoni said the agreement was verbal. Chaskalson questioned how the arrangement could demonstrate compliance with local-content requirements without documentary evidence of the local partner's contribution.
  2. 4. He denied allegations of coercion
    Statements put to him alleged that payments had been made under duress and that a security company linked to his nephew had been imposed on the project. Sibanyoni denied the allegations of coercion and said he had not known about the alleged incidents involving the previous security guards.
  3. 5. WhatsApp messages raised questions about payment demands
    Messages sent by Sindani to Ntuli referred to the payment arrangement and threatened possible disruption of the operation. Sibanyoni said he had not authorised the threat and that the operation had continued.
  1. 6. The alleged R100,000 monthly demand was disputed
    Sibanyoni acknowledged discussing a local-content arrangement for the Edwin Construction contract but denied that the alleged R100,00 monthly demand had materialised.
  2. 7. His explanation of the R500 million deal messages remained unclear
    Sibanyoni said the proposed meeting had not taken place and could not clearly recall who had sent the messages. The commission questioned whether the messages were intended to arrange a meeting with him or with Sindani.
Joe "Ferarri"  Sibanyoni  testifying at the Madlanga Commission on 28 August 2026. Picture: Katlego Jiyane/EWN
Joe "Ferarri" Sibanyoni testifying at the Madlanga Commission on 28 August 2026. Picture: Katlego Jiyane/EWN

QUESTIONS RAISED OVER R30M SHOSHOLOZA STOKVEL TRANSFER

Sibanyoni’s testimony focused on the Shosholoza Stokvel, the movement of approximately R30 million through his company, Malambule Property Developments and payments to club members. Sibanyoni’s legal team objected to the disclosure of the bank statements. His lawyer argued that the Shosholoza Stokvel was a private financial arrangement between individuals and questioned why its banking information was being presented publicly without a clear explanation of its relevance. The evidence leader explained the purpose of tracing the money. He said some contributions, which emanated from Calvin Mahlangu, owner of Gubis85 Solutions, were under investigation due an alleged fraudulent tender with the TMPD. 1. Shosholoza’s membership extended beyond the two families named in its constitution. Sibanyoni described the club as a savings scheme in which members made monthly contributions and received distributions at the end of the year. He confirmed that eight people contributed, including friends and other individuals who were not members of the two families specified in the constitution. He acknowledged that the constitution did not provide for this broader membership. 2. R30 million was transferred from the club to Sibanyoni’s company. Bank statements showed that R30 million was transferred from Shosholoza to Malambula Property Developments on 6 December 2025. Sibanyoni confirmed that Malambula was his company and that the money was intended to be distributed to club members. 3. Sibanyoni said the transfer to Malambula was a banking error.
He testified that the R30 million should have been transferred to the club’s holding account before being paid out to members. He said he mistakenly transferred it to Malambula instead, describing this as an error he had made before. 4. Sibanyoni confirmed receiving R4 million from the club.
The evidence leader pointed to a R1 million payment to Sibanyoni’s company, M&J Transport, on 21 November, followed by a R3 million transfer to Sibanyoni personally on 6 January. Sibanyoni confirmed the payments, which the evidence leader said totalled R4 million. 5. Questions were raised about payments to people outside the club.
The bank statements included a R250,000 payment to an account associated with Mr Masala, whom the evidence leader said was not a club member. Sibanyoni suggested it may have related to a loan but said he could not clearly recall the details. 6. The distribution of the money raised questions about differences in payouts.
The evidence leader examined payments to individual members and questioned why Sibanyoni appeared to receive more than other members. The figures discussed included approximately R4.05 million for several members and a larger total for Sibanyoni, depending on how certain payments were allocated. Sibanyoni said some payments were collective decisions, including money used for a celebration honouring the King. 7. Sibanyoni could not account for the remaining R865,000.
When asked about a balance of R865,000 reflected in the bank statements, Sibanyoni said he could not explain it offhand and suggested that another bank statement might clarify what happened to the money. He also said interest earned by the club was intended for charitable donations and support for vulnerable people. 8. The evidence leader linked the transactions to the commission’s investigation into TMPD payments. The evidence leader said the purpose of examining the bank statements was to trace money entering the club, including funds originating, at least in part, from payments by the Tshwane Metro Police Department (TMPD) through Calvin Mahlangu. He said the commission would need to consider the significance of those flows after Mahlangu had testified. 9. The commission raised fairness concerns about possible findings against Sibanyoni. A commissioner said that if the evidence leader intended to ask the commission to draw conclusions implicating Sibanyoni, those inferences needed to be put to him so he could respond. The evidence leader said he could not yet do so before Mahlangu had testified. The matter was left open for consideration after Mahlangu’s evidence. Sibanyoni was excused after completing his evidence. In his closing remarks, he thanked the commissioners, his legal team and his family, while expressing concern about what he described as negative narratives about him. Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.