Parliament’s Impeachment Committee has filed a response to the legal challenges brought by the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) and the African Legal Professionals Association against its process to appoint an evidence leader for the Section 89 inquiry.

Last month, the committee rescinded a decision to recommend Durban advocate Thandazani Madonsela for the role because of legal advice he’s offered to the African National Congress (ANC) on this matter.

ALSO READ:

Impeachment Committee holds off considering further nominations for evidence leader

Impeachment Committee facing legal challenges over rescinding evidence leader recommendation

Committee votes to restart process for evidence leader after debate over Madonsela's ANC ties

The evidence leader is expected to steer the questioning into the theft of US dollars from President Cyril Ramaphosa’s Phala Phala farm in 2020.

In a replying affidavit to the Western Cape High Court, the committee said by approaching the courts, the applicants are asking it to decide on Parliament’s legal counsel and to convert a professional recommendation into an entitlement.

The African Legal Professionals Association wants the High Court to set aside the Impeachment Committee’s decision to backtrack on a recommendation to appoint Madonsela as the inquiry’s evidence leader, arguing that in so doing, the committee misconstrued its powers, behaved irrationally, acted arbitrarily and in bad faith.

In a similar application, the EFF argues the committee used its numbers to unlawfully reverse the decision.

However, committee chairperson Makashule Gana said after the committee took a decision to recommend Madonsela, no further action was taken.

He points out that no instruction was given to the State attorney to appoint him, no agreement was concluded, neither was a brief issued.

Gana argues that the committee’s decision to rescind its decision after new information came to light that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest carries no legal effect.

“We believe we were within our rights and powers to rescind our own decision. In the meantime, the committee will look to finalise the terms of reference.”

Gana said only the Constitutional Court can decide whether the committee is failing to carry out the process as intended by the supreme law.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.