A legal battle is brewing in the Pretoria High Court over the lawfulness of the appointed council for gender based violence and femicide and the validity of the law relied upon for its appointment.

At the end of July, President Cyril Ramaphosa announced the appointment of the nine-member council to serve until 2029.

In a statement, Ramaphosa says he expects the council to leverage the classification of gender-based violence and femicide as a national disaster to challenge harmful attitudes and practices, and advance women’s economic empowerment, strengthen law enforcement and scale up survivor-centred support.

But just weeks after this announcement, the country faced another wave of GBV-related killings, this time mainly around Ekurhuleni, with 10 bodies discovered in the area to date and another discovered in Moroka in Soweto, added the investigation.

These events come 10 months after GBV was declared a national disaster by government, a move that did not unlock any additional funding from government but was supposed to result in departments reprioritizing their budgets and allocating funds towards the fight against GBV.

But a coalition of civil society organizations calling #Notfitforpurpose and the Call to Action collective have called the classification a joke.

They are also challenging the lawfulness of the National Council on Gender Based Violence Act.

“This declaration was a joke. First of all, around the time that this declaration was made, we had already launched a campaign that says this [ the council] is not fit for purpose… we are still fighting over the ineffectiveness of a council which at the time was being pushed forward as a response.” Sibongile Ndashe.

PRETORIA HIGH COURT BATTLE

Organisations wise for Afrika, Initiative for Strategic Litigation in Africa, One in Nine Campaign, and Mgobozi Developmental Initiatives are leading the court battle and they have taken the President, Parliament, the Speaker, the Department of Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities (DWYPD), and other involved parties to court.

The main argument made by the collective is that the National Council on Gender Based Violence Act is not reasonably capable of fulfilling the constitutional and statutory purpose for which the Council was established.

They argue that the Act fails to adequately provide for sufficient monitoring and information-gathering powers.

The organisations believe the council is a ‘dog without teeth’ with no real powers to hold government or anyone accountable for inaction when it comes to GBV.

The group plans to escalate its bid to the Constitutional Court because they believe the act is inconsistent with the Constitution.

WHAT HAPPENED SINCE THE CLASSIFICATION?

There remain more questions than answers about what happened after GBV was classified. Mainly because a Classification, by law, does not prompt the president and government to unlock new funds to address GBV.

Upon classification in November 2025, a document of the strategy and priorities post-classification was published by the Cooperative Governance Department and the DWYPD.

The Department of Women had the task of coordinating the work of each department to ensure they make provision for anti-GBV efforts.

But the department’s spokesperson, Cassius Selala, has admitted to EWN that they do not know exactly how much each department has spent.

“They are not able to tell us how much they are spending, it is because in the Department of Basic Education there is no specific programme that says gender based violence and femicide. You find that in the Department of Women. Their responsibility is within the programme of education. Issues related to GBV are being taught at school. That’s why we are unable to feel and touch at this particular point in time how much basic education is spending.”

This means that the department cannot, at this stage, 10 months since the classification, give any detail on how much money has been spent towards the fight against GBV.

Meanwhile, as more bodies continue to be discovered, with arrests being made for only one, police are on the hunt for the perpetrators behind the murders.

At the same time, Ramaphosa has promised to give an update soon on the steps government is taking to fight GBV.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.