The Electoral Court has dismissed an application by the uMkhonto WeSizwe Party (MK) challenging the integrity and reliability of the Electoral Commission's digital votes capturing and reporting the system.
The party alleged that it was robbed of votes during the 2024 national and provincial polls during a blackout of the leaderboard at the national results operations centre during the vote count.
But the court on Friday held that the MKP’s application to review the declaration of results was not competent in law.
It said that the MKP’s version put to the court was based on inferences, and it had not demonstrated that the Electoral Commission’s results system lacked integrity.
The MKP alleged that when the leader board and dashboard went blank and displayed zero results for almost two hours, it allowed for the manipulation of results.
But in its ruling, the court said the party had not followed procedure in lodging an objection with the Commission within the legally-stipulated timeframe and therefore the review of results had failed in law.
The court said it had to prefer the version put by the Commission which was based on proven and undisputed facts.
These include that despite the blackout, the entire results system continued to run and remain fully operational and uncompromised.
The court has accepted that the audit trail demonstrated that the results continued to be captured and edited during the blackout, and no data was lost.
The appeal court further agreed with the evidence that showed the incident had no impact on the capturing and verification of results.
Despite being offered an opportunity to amend its request to the court, the court said the MKP had failed to introduce a new factual case and had failed to make out a case for the relief it sought.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.