So you give a political party your vote, only for it to later jump into bed and form a coalition with a party you would never have supported.
It's one of the pitfalls of coalition politics and raises the question of whether parties should be forced to tell voters before an election who they are prepared to team up with.
Independent elections analyst Michael Atkins believes greater transparency is good in principle, but warned against imposing too many rules.
Speaking to CapeTalk’s Lester Kiewit, Atkins said the voter’s right to know is valued highly in a democracy.
"Anything that gives the voters more information is, in a sense, unarguable... the only difficulty, and I'm not saying it's an absolute, but the only difficulty is you might box parties in by making public declarations."
ALSO READ: Can the Coalition Bill stop 'revolving-door' mayors?
Can we slap rules on political coalitions?
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
Civil society organisation My Vote Counts says that coalition agreements should be made public and believes that voters should be told which parties could potentially govern together.
It says this type of transparency allows voters to understand what policy compromises parties may make and provides a basis on which they can later be held accountable.
Atkins said one of the issues with forcing parties to make commitments ahead of an election is that the eventual results may leave them facing circumstances they could not have anticipated.
Coalition negotiations can differ significantly from municipality to municipality, and parties may need to compromise to establish functioning councils.
“There might be compromises needed. There might be positions that are hard to take back if they are made public beforehand," said Atkins.
At the same time, he warned that political parties could not simply abandon their principles once the votes had been counted.
“Nobody likes a party or a person who just throws over their principles at the drop of a hat.”
Atkins described the 'fine tension' between allowing parties room to negotiate while ensuring voters know as much as possible about who and what they are voting for.
“I think too much of our legislation is built around the needs of parties, and not enough around the needs and interests of voters,” he said.
The debate comes as Parliament considers the Local Government: Municipal Structures Amendment Bill, also referred to as the Coalitions Bill.
The bill was introduced in Parliament in August and seeks to create a legal framework for coalition governments and provide for formal coalition agreements.
Parliament has said one of the proposals would require written coalition agreements to be submitted to municipal and provincial authorities and published.
But Atkins has reservations about trying to solve political problems related to coalitions only through legislation.
He gave the example of Denmark, where coalition politics works through an established culture of negotiation rather than rules that force parties to behave in a certain way.
“If people are acting in bad faith, then they are just going to shift the boundaries of their bad faith to where the law sits,” he said.
“How do you compel people to form agreements? How do you force them to sign a contract?”
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.