The Democratic Alliance's Helen Zille says some political parties are undermining voters' right to know who could represent them in council by submitting just one candidate on their proportional representation (PR) lists ahead of the upcoming municipal elections.
But election management expert Terry Tselane disputes the argument, saying the law allows parties to supplement their lists after the election results are announced.
The dispute centres on parties including ActionSA, the EFF, the MK Party and GOOD, which have submitted single-name PR lists in some municipalities despite potentially winning multiple PR seats.
Zille, the DA’s Johannesburg mayoral candidate, says the practice raises questions about the democratic process and the intention of amendments to the Municipal Structures Act.
Tselane, the Executive Chairman of the Institute of Election Management Services in Africa, says the legislation provides for parties to add candidates if they win more seats than they initially listed.
The disagreement comes as the DA prepares to approach the courts over its interpretation of the law.
RELATED: Zille defers Johannesburg Council decision until after DA Federal Congress
Parties submit single PR candidate lists
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
Zille: Voters have a right to know who they are voting for
Zille says parties previously submitted one name on their PR lists and supplemented them after the election, before the first council meeting.
She argues that amendments to the Municipal Structures Act in 2021 were intended, in part, to prevent this practice.
“When voters are voting for a party that is unlikely to win any ward seats but likely to win quite a few proportional list seats,” Zille said, the list becomes particularly important.
She cited ActionSA and the EFF as examples of parties that could win several PR seats but few, if any, ward seats.
“The idea of the amendment was to make it more democratic, to say voters, and this is about voters, not rewarding candidates who worked hard in the election. Voters have a right to know who they are voting for.”
Zille said the Electoral Commission of South Africa (IEC) publishes candidate lists so voters can see the names in their order of precedence.
She argued that parties should not submit only one name if they know they are likely to win more than one PR seat.
“And it's bad faith to do so. And in fact, it could be seen as fraudulent in certain interpretations of the Constitution and the law as we read it.”
Zille said the DA was going to court to seek a declaratory order on the issue.
She argued that allowing party leaders to decide who fills additional PR seats after the election would deny voters the opportunity to know who could represent them.
“They're saying to the voters, we don't give you a chance to choose who you want to be elected. Just vote for us, blind, fly blind in good faith, and let us choose after the election.”
ActionSA says it wants to assess candidates after the election
ActionSA said it had deliberately submitted only one name on its PR list in Johannesburg: its mayoral candidate, Herman Mashaba.
In a written response read during the interview, the party said it intended to supplement its list according to the number of seats it won.
The party said the supplemented list would be based on the outcomes of ward candidates across the city.
It added that candidates had been given key performance indicators by regional and provincial leadership, and that additional factors, including skills and representation, would be considered when compiling the list.
ActionSA said the IEC allowed political parties to supplement their PR lists based on the number of seats they secured.
Tselane: The law allows parties to supplement their lists
Tselane offered a different interpretation of the legislation, saying parties that receive more seats than the number of candidates on their lists are entitled to supplement those lists.
He referred to provisions in the Municipal Structures Act dealing with parties that win more seats than they initially submitted candidates for.
Tselane said the chief electoral officer would notify a party if its list contained fewer candidates than the number of seats it was entitled to fill.
He said the party would then be required to submit additional names within two days of receiving the notice.
“If a party list contains fewer candidates than the party is entitled to, the chief electoral officer must, in writing, immediately notify the party of the exact shortfall and request the party to deliver within two days of the notice, a list supplemented by the name or names of one or more eligible candidates.”
Tselane said the amendment Zille referred to specified the period within which a party had to respond to such a notice.
He said the process would take place after the election results were announced and before the first council meeting.
Is submitting one name undemocratic?
Asked whether voters should know the names of all the candidates who could represent a party in council, Tselane said the question of whether the practice was democratic was separate from the legal provisions.
He argued that voters choose parties based on their confidence in the party and its mandate, rather than necessarily choosing each individual on its list.
“I don't buy the argument that if you are electing a party, necessarily... you've got to know each and every person who is actually in that list.”
Tselane also said the law did not require every party to submit a full list of candidates.
“The provision only requires a political party to submit the names not more than the number of seats available in that particular municipality.”
He said a party might initially believe it would win only one seat but then secure more seats than expected.
In that case, he said, the law provides for the list to be supplemented with the names of candidates who would fill the additional positions.
Zille, however, maintains that parties should submit a coherent list of candidates in ranked order, based on the number of seats they believe they could win.
She argues that parties should not be allowed to use the post-election process to select candidates voters had not been able to see before voting.
What happens next?
The dispute raises questions about how parties should compile their PR lists and what voters should be able to know about potential councillors before an election.
Zille says the DA is seeking a court ruling on its interpretation of the law and the purpose of the 2021 amendments.
Tselane maintains that the legislation allows parties to supplement their lists after the election if they win more seats than they initially submitted candidates for.
The interview ended with the DA's planned court action still to come, leaving the competing interpretations unresolved.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.