The Electoral Commission of South Africa (IEC) has termed the African National Congress (ANC)’s legal challenge against its candidate submission procedure as “stillborn”.

As the party on Tuesday appeared to abandon its claims of system glitches for the mishap, the commission told the Electoral Court that the ANC simply ran out of time to submit its candidates' list for six municipalities in accordance with the regulations.

ALSO READ:

ANC fights to contest 6 municipalities after missing candidate list deadline

IEC tells court ANC uploaded candidate lists five minutes before deadline

ANC hadn’t submitted candidates’ lists for almost all municipalities 2 days before deadline: IEC

However, the party insisted that the requirement of pressing a final submit button on the IEC’s online system is merely “cosmetic” and a “design choice” of the commission, and not part of the rules.

In a virtual hearing of the court, the IEC’s legal counsel, Advocate Terry Motau, questioned why the ANC has never disputed the commission’s online candidate nomination system in the past.

He said the ANC’s claims of technical glitches for not submitting the lists as final by the August deadline had been damaging to the electoral process.

“The aspersions that had been cast on the system, which go to impugning the integrity of this process, cannot be side-stepped now because the ANC has changed its heart and to run a different case than what it had run throughout.”

But the ANC’s legal counsel, Advocate Daniel Berger, said the technical problems are irrelevant to the crux of its case.

Instead, the ANC centred its arguments on the view that by having already uploaded the details of candidates before the cut-off, the captured information should be deemed as a final submission.

“The non-pressing of the button does not exclude you as a candidate, does not disqualify you from participating in the election, then it doesn’t matter why you didn’t press the button.”

Judge Lebogang Modiba said this is a difficult matter to adjudicate, but that the court would endeavour to hand down judgment on Wednesday.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.