President Ramaphosa is asking the Western Cape High Court to cancel a report that could lead to his impeachment.

CASAC (the Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution) notes that no matter what the court decides, Parliament will learn valuable lessons from this unprecedented situation on how to handle it.

So far, Parliamentary impeachment proceedings have led to the removal of a Public Protector and two High Court judges.

ALSO READ:
Ramaphosa’s legal team urges court to dismiss Arthur Fraser’s Phala Phala affidavit as mere 'say-so'

Court challenges Phala Phala-linked questions opposition parties want Ramaphosa to answer to

MK Party accuses Ramaphosa of using 'Stalingrad tactics' to delay Phala Phala answers

CASAC’s Executive Secretary Lawson Naidoo said the current case presents an opportunity to test the strength of Parliament’s impeachment rules.

In 2017, the National Assembly was found wanting when the Constitutional Court instructed it to draft institutional steps to give effect to Section 89 of the Constitution for the impeachment of a president, following a case brought by the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) involving the personal residence of former President Jacob Zuma.

But this is the first time the rules adopted in 2018 are being put to the test, as President Cyril Ramaphosa challenges whether there’s enough evidence to force him to face impeachment over his conduct following the theft of US dollars from his Phala Phala farm.

CASAC’s Lawson Naidoo believes Ramaphosa’s legal team put up a solid case to argue that Parliament’s independent panel may not have sufficiently tested the information before it, before suggesting the president should face impeachment.

“Of course, we need to have an effective system in place, so where a president does go rogue, they can actually be held to account. So, it must never be a case where the president can get away with using a legal strategy," said Naidoo.

However, Naidoo said that the three-day hearing did reveal shortcomings in Parliament’s own rules and processes.

“I think that certainly came out in the arguments that the lacunae, or the gaps and ambiguities in the rules themselves, could be strengthened, and let’s face it, this is the first time Parliament is going through an impeachment process for a president, so it’s a learning exercise for Parliament as well," he added.

Naidoo said that while the system should never allow a president to use a legal strategy to avoid accountability, the country’s first citizen does have the right to legally challenge instances where the rules have not been met.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.