President Cyril Ramaphosa suggested that a sworn statement by former State Security head Arthur Fraser about the burglary on Ramaphosa’s Phala Phala farm should be disregarded as evidence in his impeachment.

Fraser blew the lid on the theft of 580 000 US dollars from a couch at the farm’s residence in 2022, two years after the fact, when he filed a complaint at a police station.

ALSO READ:

Court challenges Phala Phala-linked questions opposition parties want Ramaphosa to answer to

MK Party accuses Ramaphosa of using 'Stalingrad tactics' to delay Phala Phala answers

Phala Phala saga: Opposition parties claim Ramaphosa hid $580k farm theft

However, Ramaphosa’s legal team told the Western Cape High Court that Fraser’s assertions have never been tested, and the independent panel that considered whether Ramaphosa should face impeachment should have dismissed it.

Proceedings have now wrapped up after a three-day hearing in which Ramaphosa has made a bid to have the report of the independent panel set aside.

Replying to more than two days of opposition arguments from four political parties opposing the president's application, his attorney Advocate Wim Trengove said Arthur Fraser’s version of events that purportedly took place at Phala Phala in February 2020 can not be trusted.

Trengove said that Fraser has never explained the source of his information nor been asked to verify the claims he makes.

"I would submit that there’s a category difference. His statement is not hearsay; it’s just say. You don’t even know where it comes from."

Trengove said the independent panel appointed by Parliament to consider four impeachable charges against Ramaphosa should have been more circumspect about Fraser’s statement.

"I submit that they should either have disregarded it because it’s not even hearsay evidence; it’s just say evidence. Even if they took it into account, they should have attached very little weight to it."

Judge President Nolwazi Mabindla-Boqwana said the bench is mindful of the desire for a swift decision in this case, but that the court had to be given time to deal with what are very weighty matters.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.