Consumer Ninja: Counterfeit con – a consumer victory

Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype

When you are buying a branded item, especially secondhand, there is always a danger that what you're spending your money on could be a fake.

This week on The Money Show, Wendy Knowler recounts the experience of one frustrated customer to illustrate why you should always check.

The journalist recorded another consumer win when she followed up on a complaint from Mitchell Botha, who'd bought what appeared to be a Spyderco knife at a Cash Converters outlet in Germiston.

When Botha had a good look once he got home, however, he sensed something wasn't right.

Upon returning the knife, he was told that he could not get a refund.

"The store hadn't advertised the knife as authentic, Botha was told, and he should have asked the staff. He said, quite reasonably, that it was being sold as the brand and nothing anywhere said otherwise".

"Then he was told he couldn't have a refund because his was a grudge purchase - aka a 'change of heart'. If the knife stopped working within seven days they'd consider refunding him, if they were satisfied there was a fault. But not for this."

The store manager invited Botha to swap the knife, which he did and paid in the difference.

RELATED: Know your rights: Why a store's return policy isn't always the final word

Knowler cites sections of the Consumer Protection Act (CPA) and the Counterfeit Goods Act which prohibit false, misleading or deceptive representations to protect the consumer.

When she contacted Richard Mukheibir, chairperson of Cash Converters Southern Africa, he acknowledged it was apparent they had dropped the ball, "specifically with how we handled Mr Botha's return to the store."

It was determined that the knife in question was in fact counterfeit and Knowler reports that the customer was refunded R1 300 for both transactions, with the second knife to be collected from him.

Every comparable knife has since been removed from display in that store, and the returned item was secured and documented so it couldn't be altered or handed back to whoever sold it in.

Wendy Knowler's advice:

  • When buying secondhand goods, examine them carefully before you leave the store - the finish, the markings and the packaging.
  • If you later think you've been sold a fake, don't let anyone tell you it's a grudge purchase. That's a different thing entirely from being sold a fake.
  • Go to the brand for verification if necessary.

For more detail, listen to Wendy Knowler's report in the interview audio at the top of the article