With mournful smiles and tears falling on their faces, Elie Challita and Amy Johnston, in their home filled with memories of their little girl who was brutally murdered, shared bits and pieces about who Nada- Jane Challita was. 

Surrounded by gymnastics certificates, art projects with the little girl’s handprint and footprint, images of her holding a fish or in the arms of her father and mother are hard to miss in their living room. Johnston and Challita say a big part of them was ripped away.

The 23rd January 2023 marks the fateful day when Amber Lee Hughes drowned the four-year-old who loved water. She would play in the bathtub for hours, he mother said with a laughter prompted by beautiful memories of her daughter.

Nada-Jane had filled her parents' days with laughter and many moments in the garden.

Pulling from the recesses of her memory, Johnston shares the first time she discovered she was expecting Nada.

“We found out after the second scan that she was a girl. She was very proud to show that she was a girl. It got very exciting after that, getting prepared for baby. And a lot of prayers, obviously. Every day, I prayed over her, prayed that God would bless her with outstanding blessings. And then the baby was born on a Sunday at 10:30am. She came very quickly.

“All I just wanted was for her to be protected from the evil world that we have out here. And then I just wanted her to have her own dreams and inspirations and be supportive and just watch her grow into this beautiful, wonderful little girl,” Johnston shared with a faraway look in her eyes.”

As Challita’s eyes glossed over, he recalled a moment that showed them how their daughter was, according to their description, a fearless child who had a great love for the outdoors and had great empathy for animals.

ALSO READ: [WATCH] Amber Lee Hughes admits to drowning 4-year-old Nada-Jane Challita

Key events in the Amber Lee Hughes case – From arrest to guilty verdict in murder of Nada-Jane

“As a child, we took her to pet shops, and she wanted rabbits; she got the rabbits. She wanted hedgehogs, she got the hedgehogs. She wanted baby ducks, she got her baby ducks. And she was running after them in the garden the whole time.

“We went fishing by the dam and by the river.

And, you know, where other kids would stand and look at the fish, she would see the fish opening and closing its mouth, and she would put her finger in the fish's mouth. So she wasn't scared of anything like that, you know. She carried the fish and released them into the water,” he fondly recounted.

Nada-Jane Challita's parents Elie Challita and Amy Johnston. Picture: Sphamandla Dlamini/EWN
Nada-Jane Challita's parents Elie Challita and Amy Johnston. Picture: Sphamandla Dlamini/EWN

Prayers were laid upon her life to be protected from harm's way. As Challita shared, he would at times pray that if anything bad were to happen, it would be directed to him and not his daughter. 

Having to reconcile the passing of their child caused by a woman they once trusted with the care of their child. Nada-Jane's father expressed regret and guilt for what befell his beloved daughter.

“I felt like I failed her, which is true. As a father. And I failed to protect her...that incident actually, like, it broke my back, you know. As a man, it broke my fatherhood. And the damage is permanent. That feeling of that day never goes away. It will forever remain with me,” he said. 

Four-year-old Nada-Jane Challita was raped and murdered in Glenvista, Johannesburg, on 23 January 2023. Picture: Sphamandla Dlamini/EWN
Four-year-old Nada-Jane Challita was raped and murdered in Glenvista, Johannesburg, on 23 January 2023. Picture: Sphamandla Dlamini/EWN

With a loss that engulfs their lives, a sense of guilt and regret still occupies Challita. Questions arise about why he had left his daughter in the hands of the woman who would not only kill but also sexually assault.

Having been in court for over three years now, facing one postponement after another, the family is left in a limbo where they have to relive the worst part of their lives. 

They shared that they cannot even begin to imagine a future, as being in court feels like salt being placed on their open wound. A wound that cannot heal as yet, as the fate of the one who was found guilty of murdering and raping their child still hangs in the balance. 

“It's blank; you don't understand there's a whole wall that covers that future, and that wall is made of what will happen at court for me…I refuse to look beyond the wall; I'm incapable anyway, so I'm fine that I'm incapable. I'm not forcing myself to look beyond the wall; I'm not rushing my future, whatever it is, so I can only see the wall of this court, and I cannot look for the future,” shared Challita. 

Nada-Jane Challita's parents Elie Challita and Amy Johnston. Picture: Sphamandla Dlamini/EWN
Nada-Jane Challita's parents Elie Challita and Amy Johnston. Picture: Sphamandla Dlamini/EWN

Life has shifted tremendously from what it used to be to what it is now; both parents are stuck and not able to even visit their family or friends due to the case. Anger, hurt, and disappointment in the justice system accompany the parents. As they live in this new reality, they shared what they said about their little girl. 

“She will never not be a part of our life.  Even though she's not here, she's in our hearts," said Challita. 

"I kind of, I see little dandelions flying around or butterflies or birds or beautiful sunsets and I just look up to heaven and say thank you, Nada, for bringing this beautiful reminder that she's still with us," shared Johnston.  

As Nada-Jane's family continues to battle with the case that has gone on for years, Challita is preparing to submit his evidence to the High Court as part of the sentencing proceedings on Thursday, 27 August 2027.

Four-year-old Nada-Jane Challita was raped and murdered in Glenvista, Johannesburg, on 23 January 2023. Picture: Sphamandla Dlamini/EWN
Four-year-old Nada-Jane Challita was raped and murdered in Glenvista, Johannesburg, on 23 January 2023. Picture: Sphamandla Dlamini/EWN

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.