Cape Town’s dam levels have fallen to 77.7%, according to a City of Cape Town graph referenced by climate scientist Peter Johnston, leaving them 12.9 percentage points lower than at the same time last year.
The decline has raised questions about whether the city should introduce more stringent water restrictions, particularly as memories of the 2017 water crisis and the threat of Day Zero remain fresh.
But Johnston, an independent applied climatologist, said there is reason for a more measured approach.
He said Cape Town is not currently facing a Day Zero situation, although another year of poor rainfall could put the city in a serious drought.
RELATED: Cape Town must look into ways to reduce water demand, says climatologist Peter Johnston
Dry winter puts Cape Town’s water supply on alert
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
Rainfall has actually been unusually high
Johnston said rainfall in the areas supplying Cape Town's dams has been well above average so far this year.
In fact, he said it is in the top 10% of rainfall accumulations in the history of rainfall in the dam catchment areas.
The city has received 127mm more rainfall than the long-term average so far this year, according to Johnston.
He said Cape Town has also almost received as much rain as it did during the whole of last year, with just 39mm separating the two totals.
The problem is when that rain has fallen.
“What's been dire is that June, July and August have been well below normal,” Johnston said.
He pointed to extreme rainfall in May, when the city received 250% of the expected rainfall.
This unusual distribution of rainfall, combined with falling dam levels, creates a difficult decision for planners.
“Are we going to be able to cope if we have a third year which is a little bit less than normal or around normal?” Johnston asked.
Should Cape Town introduce tougher restrictions?
The City currently has water restrictions in place, but there has been discussion about whether further restrictions should be introduced before the national Department of Water and Sanitation conducts an assessment in November.
Johnston said the city does not necessarily have to wait for that assessment before acting.
However, he believes the current approach of holding off on tougher restrictions is reasonable.
Rather than immediately imposing additional restrictions, Johnston believes the city should focus on encouraging residents, businesses and other water users to reduce unnecessary consumption.
“Everybody must be aware that water is a valuable resource and none of us should be wasting water,” he said.
Johnston said the city could monitor consumption over several weeks and use the results to determine whether stronger measures are necessary.
If consumption is not falling, he said, the city could then make the case for additional restrictions.
Avoiding panic
Johnston said another poor rainfall year could change the picture significantly.
“And then of course it's panic stations, and we must always avoid panic stations,” Johnston said.
For now, he believes the focus should be on reducing waste while avoiding unnecessarily punitive restrictions.
He said the city should consider where the biggest savings can be made, including wastage and unnecessary demand.
The aim, he said, should be to control consumption while ensuring that water restrictions do not unfairly affect people who have less ability to absorb the costs.
The latest figure cited in the interview showed Cape Town using 847 million litres of water a day; 13 million litres below the 860-million-litre limit set for this period.
For Johnston, the immediate message is therefore less about panic over Day Zero and more about making sure Cape Town does not become complacent about its water supply.