The State succeeded in reopening its case against Sthembiso Mdlalose, who is accused of starting the deadly Usindiso fire in 2023.
Prosecutors brought forward their application in the Johannesburg High Court sitting in Palm Ridge on Monday afternoon.
ALSO READ: [WATCH] ‘I am fighting for my life here’ - Sthembiso Mdlalose
The application follows a directive to address discrepancies in evidence about the identities of some of the 76 people killed in the blaze.
Mdlalose is accused of mass murder after allegedly setting fire to someone he claimed to have killed, with the flames then spreading through the five-storey building.
Judge Cassim Moosa ruled that reopening the State’s case was in the interests of justice.
"It is the considered view of this court that if this application were not to succeed, it would be a travesty of justice, not only to both the parties, but to the victims as well as their relatives, the surviving relatives. And at the end of the day, as was stated in the case of Arr v. Hepworth, this is simply not a game."
Sthembiso Mdlalose clashed with his lawyer in court on Monday after judgment in his case was delayed.
Mdlalose returned to the Johannesburg High Court sitting in Palm Ridge on Monday expecting to learn his fate.
However, that did not happen after the State applied to reopen its case over evidence related to the identities of some of the 76 people killed in the fire.
Mdlalose is accused of starting the blaze in August 2023, allegedly to cover up another murder at the hijacked inner-city building.
He faces 76 counts of murder as well as multiple counts of attempted murder.
Mdlalose was involved in a tense exchange with his lawyer, appearing unhappy with how his legal representative handled the State’s application.
Mdlalose made it clear he was in court to hear his fate, even rising from the dock and addressing the judge out of turn.
His lawyer did not oppose the State’s application, fuelling Mdlalose’s frustration.
When the matter was postponed, Mdlalose stormed out of court.
He later returned to question his lawyer, asking whether he was still representing his interests.
The case returns to court on Wednesday, when the State is expected to formally reopen its case
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.