South Africa has spent almost R300 million repatriating foreign nationals, with nearly 90,000 people removed as part of the government's migration crackdown.
But a senior research consultant at the African Centre for Migration & Society at Wits University has said the numbers don't actually speak to either the success or failure of the strategy.
Dr Rebecca Walker told 702 that a strategy can only be deemed effective when it produces the outcome it was designed to.
The question that needs to be asked, she said, is 'what was the aim?'.
"If it was to reduce unemployment, that's unchanged, if not worse. If it was a more orderly migration system, we have less of one than we had before. We have burnt regional relationships. We've created our own crisis."
Walker said the government efficiently carried out the operation of removing people, but whether that operation actually solved the problem is a completely different question.
"If we're measuring success by just a number of removals, then we really need to look at what problem we were trying to solve and has it been solved?
702's Bongani Bingwa asked how many repatriated migrants would return to South Africa.
For Walker, even calling the process 'repatriation' is disingenuous.
"Repatriation is returning people when they want to go back to a place, or they need to go back. This wasn't repatriation....This was moving people who had been forcibly chased out of their communities."
She noted also that the government had spent R48 million on a temporary repatriation centre designed for 20,000 people, but which only ever saw just over 1,000 occupants at any one time.
Who is accountable for that, she asked.
ALSO READ:
BMA battles return of undocumented foreign nationals after recent mass deportations
More than 68k undocumented foreign nationals leave SA, confirms Ntshaveni
Migration policy success should be measured by lawfulness, not numbers – researcher
Is deportation solving the illegal immigration crisis?
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
Another issue that deserves scrutiny, Walker suggested, is who had benefited financially from the operation.
"We should be asking how a government has run an operation of this scale outside its own legal and financial framework, and it's calling it successful policy. Who got those contracts?"
It's a question that has yet to be asked in Parliament, says Walker
She also focused on how removing migrants had failed to address the underlying issues.
"All we've done is make the situation much worse and not address the underlying conditions, which ultimately we know are about unemployment, poverty, poor service delivery, none of which removing migrants is going to fix."
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.