Home Affairs Minister Leon Schreiber and Immigration Authority Board Chairperson Mavuso Msimang defended immigration attorney Stefanie de Saude-Darbandi's seat on the advisory board following public backlash regarding her ongoing litigation against the state.

De Saude-Darbandi represents beauty queen Chidimma Adetshina, who is challenging her citizenship after the Department of Home Affairs moved against her mother for fraudulently obtaining South African citizenship prior to her birth.

ALSO READ: Lawyers for finalist Chidimma Adetshina's mother believe they have a strong case

However, both Schreiber and Msimang stated they failed to see how this constituted the conflict of interest raised in more than 200 public submissions submitted to Parliament’s portfolio committee.

Minister Leon Schreiber said that, according to the Immigration Act, members of the Immigration Authority Board served in an advisory capacity on immigration matters and did not handle individual immigration cases or legal challenges against the state.

Schreiber said that experts like attorney Stefanie de Saude-Darbandi offered divergent views and acted as a soundboard on shortcomings within the immigration system.

However, he was not compelled to accept their advice.

"As for the specific issue of one specific court case, there would be no way that is relevant to the work of the board or considered there," he said.

IAB Chairperson Mavuso Msimang said he too failed to understand the public perception that De Saude-Darbandi was conflicted by her job as an immigration attorney serving on the board.

"I really tried to figure out how a mischievous board member could have a chance of influencing any case in their interest. I don’t see a conflict of interest," he said.

However, the majority of MPs were not satisfied with the explanations.

Committee Chairperson Mosa Chabane said that Parliament would continue to debate the matter, including whether changes needed to be made to the act regarding the criteria for selecting board members.