Parliament's Impeachment Committee has engaged in heated debate on what would be considered sufficient evidence to determine whether President Cyril Ramaphosa misconducted himself in connection with the Phala Phala matter.
While the ANC has suggested the committee may decide not to proceed with a full-blown inquiry once it has reviewed the evidence before it, the EFF has dismissed this suggestion, saying the Section 89 process is already well underway.
The committee has now agreed to adopt a parliamentary legal opinion that has advised that the Constitution and the law be the guide on determining the standard of proof.
Parliament's legal advisors have recommended the committee follow the process of the Section 194 inquiry, which considered the impeachment of former Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane in 2022, in deciding on the charges President Ramaphosa is facing.
ALSO READ:
ANC accused of delaying tactics for doubting Parly’s legal advice to Impeachment Committee
But ANC MP Faith Muthambi has questioned whether the bar is clear enough.
"What is the standard of proof to establish the sufficiency of evidence according to the principle of legality?"
ActionSA's Athol Trollip said he believed the balance of probabilities should be the standard, and reminded his colleagues that the inquiry is not a court of law, nor would it be the final arbiter on the matter.
" We must apply the law. We must listen to the evidence, and based on the evidence that we hear and based on the balance of probability as opposed to beyond reasonable doubt."
MK Party's parliamentary leader John Hlophe said the terms of reference for the inquiry need to include clear and specific definitions for the test that will be used to assess the evidence.