The Gauteng High Court has declared the suspension of Public Investment Corporation (PIC) CEO Patrick Dlamini unlawful, ruling that the board acted outside its powers when it placed him on precautionary suspension.
The judgment marks a dramatic twist in the governance crisis at Africa's largest asset manager.
Judge Mandla Mbongwe found that the board failed to follow both the PIC Act and its own delegations of authority before suspending Dlamini on the 13th of July.
The court held that the board did not have the legal authority to act unilaterally and that the required ministerial approval process was not followed.
The judgment states that only the finance minister in consultation with cabinet has the authority to appoint the PIC's chief executive.
While any suspension under the PIC's delegations of authority must first be recommended by the Human Resources and Remuneration Committee, initiated by the chairperson and approved by the minister.
None of those steps were followed.
The court also rejected arguments that the PIC's Whistleblower Policy gave the board the power to suspend Dlamini, saying whistleblower protections guard against retaliation but do not create powers that override legislation or the corporation's governing framework.
The court has now set aside Dlamini's suspension, dismissed attempts by intervening parties to join the proceedings, and ordered the respondents to pay the legal costs of the application.