The trial-within-a-trial in the case against alleged underworld figure Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala and four others has turned into a fierce legal battle over the alleged violation of accused number one Musa Kekana's constitutional rights.

Despite repeated denials by the State's key witness, on Thursday the defence produced hospital records to support allegations of assault and repeated suffocation during Kekana's arrest.

ALSO READ:

Matlala trial: Alleged hitman produces hospital records to prove torture claims

'Cat' Matlala trial: Accused claims he was tortured by cops after his arrest

Matlala trial: Defence accuses lead officer of fabricating details in Musa Kekana's arrest

With the legality of the arrest and the admissibility of key evidence under scrutiny, the State faces the task of convincing the court that the disputed evidence should be admitted.

On Friday morning, State witness Captain Pimi Sekgobela is expected to return to the Johannesburg High Court for a fifth day under cross-examination.

On Thursday, the defence made shocking allegations of torture, claiming Kekana was repeatedly suffocated with a plastic courier bag, assaulted and forced to make admissions after his arrest.

Representing accused number one Kekana, who is challenging the legality of his arrest and the evidence obtained thereafter, Advocate Riaan Gissing relied on hospital records, which he said document allegations of assault and record that Kekana's condition of coughing up blood worsened after he was allegedly suffocated.

“The portion that I refer your Lordship to is that 17 April 2024 in brackets. After, and I read from the document, being allegedly suffocated with a plastic bag plus multiple punches on the chest.”

Sekgobela, against whom a large part of the allegations have been made and who, at times, couldn’t remember aspects of what happened on the day Kekana was arrested, denies every allegation.

He insists Kekana was never assaulted or tortured and that police called an ambulance when he began coughing during a search at the house.

Sekgobela denied that he was not permitted to enter and search Kekana's property.

It also emerged that Kekana was only made to sign the SAP14 A form that explains his constitutional rights only two days after his arrest while in hospital, sharply contrasting Sekgobela's version.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.