The Public Investment Corporation’s (PIC) deal involving Lanseria International Airport has become a complicated web of loans, shareholdings and sharply differing valuations.

At the heart of it is a relatively simple question: How did a BEE partner that was funded by the PIC to acquire a stake in Lanseria, and subsequently failed to repay its loan, end up in a position where the PIC had to make a payment of more than R400 million?

Analyst and chartered accountant Khaya Sithole says understanding the answer requires going back to how the Lanseria transaction was originally structured.

And central to what happened next is the value placed on the airport, a figure Sithole says changed dramatically during 2024.

RELATED: SIU to probe controversial Acapulco-Lanseria transaction

The Public Investment Corporation (PIC) Lanseria deal explained  

Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype

How the Lanseria deal worked

Sithole explained that the Lanseria ownership structure involved three parties.

The PIC itself held a direct stake of around 37.5%, while the Pan African Infrastructure Development Fund held another 37.5%.

The remaining 25% was held by a BEE partner, which had been funded by the PIC to participate in the transaction.

According to Sithole, the PIC loan was around R330 million and was due to be repaid after 10 years.

The basic premise was that the investment in Lanseria would generate returns that could be used to service the debt.

“The hope was that you buy Lanseria, you operate Lanseria, Lanseria does very well, [it] grows profits, and then you guys will take your share of the profits, and you'll pay the loan,” Sithole explained.

But that did not happen.

Sithole said the borrower was already struggling to service the loan before the Covid-19 pandemic hit in 2020.

The pandemic subsequently devastated the aviation industry and fundamentally changed the conditions under which Lanseria operated, but Sithole stressed that the loan's problems predated Covid.

“The loan was in default long before then, so there was a continuous struggle over the years to simply honour the terms of this agreement.”

By 2023, the 10th anniversary of the loan had arrived, and the debt could not be settled.

That left the PIC with a decision about what to do next.

Why the PIC took the shares

Sithole cautioned against assuming that all PIC loans work in the same way.

The structure of individual transactions can differ, including how capital and interest are repaid and what happens when unexpected events affect an investment.

But the fundamental principle, he said, is that a loan still has to be repaid.

“The PIC must recover what it lent out. It must recover the capital and must recover the interest.”

In the Lanseria transaction, the agreement provided for the PIC to step in and take over the shares acquired using its financing if the borrower defaulted.

That process was initiated after it became clear the loan could not be repaid.

This was not necessarily an unattractive outcome for the PIC, Sithole explained, because it was already an investor in Lanseria and therefore already believed there was an investment case for owning the airport.

Taking over the BEE partner's 25% stake would, according to Sithole, increase the PIC's direct holding from around 37.5% to 62.5%.

But taking the shares did not end the matter.

The crucial question became: What were those shares actually worth?

That is where the deal becomes significantly more complicated.

Why a default could still result in a R400m-plus payment

When the PIC moved to take the 25% stake, the underlying asset had to be valued.

Sithole explained that determining the value of a quarter of the company first required determining what Lanseria itself was worth.

That valuation could then be compared with the amount owed to the PIC.

According to Sithole, the debt had grown to around R600 million.

If the 25% stake surrendered to the PIC was worth less than that amount, the PIC would effectively be receiving an asset worth less than the outstanding debt.

But if the shares were valued at more than the debt, the difference could result in a cash payment.

“You have to compare two numbers, which were the R600 million that they owe you versus the value of the 25% that you're getting, and the difference between the two forms the basis of the cash exchange,” Sithole said.

That made the valuation of Lanseria enormously consequential.

Sithole said both parties had to agree on the valuer appointed to determine the value of the shares.

The valuation firm was expected to be independent and competent, but the parties could still disagree with the number it produced.

And that, according to Sithole, is precisely what happened.

From R283m for the stake to around R1bn

Sithole said BDO initially valued the 25% shareholding at R283 million.

Against debt of roughly R600 million, that would have meant the shares were worth substantially less than the amount owed to the PIC.

But Sithole said the BEE partner rejected that valuation.

BDO was subsequently terminated and another valuer, Crowe, came on board.

According to Sithole, Crowe initially produced a valuation of approximately R2.2 billion for the entire Lanseria business.

At that valuation, a 25% stake would be worth about R550 million, still below the roughly R600 million owed to the PIC.

Then came another valuation.

Sithole said Crowe's final valuation placed the entire business at roughly R4.1 billion.

That would put the value of a 25% stake at around R1 billion.

The implications were dramatically different.

Instead of the shares being worth less than the outstanding debt, they were now worth hundreds of millions of rand more.

That difference, Sithole explained, was what resulted in the PIC having to make a payment of more than R400 million.

The valuation swing

It is the trajectory of Lanseria's valuations that Sithole believes demands particular scrutiny.

He said Lanseria was valued at around R900 million in March 2020, shortly before the effects of Covid-19 hit the aviation industry.

Later in 2020, he said, its value had dropped to around R520 million.

The PIC, as a shareholder, was required to value its investment every year, Sithole explained.

According to the figures he cited, the PIC valued Lanseria at around R500 million in 2022 and R464 million in 2023.

In March 2024, he said, the PIC's valuation remained at R464 million.

Then the numbers began rising sharply.

Sithole said BDO valued the same asset at around R1.1 billion in June 2024, three months after the PIC's R464 million valuation.

Crowe subsequently produced the roughly R2.2 billion valuation before its final valuation put the figure at around R4.1 billion.

That meant the stated value of Lanseria had moved from R464 million in March to roughly R4.1 billion later in 2024.

“You had a tenfold increase in the value of this asset [from] March to November 2024,” Sithole said.

“Everybody can see that there's something seriously wrong with these numbers.”

Sithole also questioned the scale of the change between Crowe's initial and final figures.

He said PwC, which was subsequently asked to examine the matter, was unable to get an explanation directly from Crowe.

According to Sithole, PwC instead had access to communications showing the differing figures.

For the PIC, the consequences of which valuation was accepted were substantial.

At the lower end, the 25% stake would have been worth considerably less than the approximately R600 million owed to it.

At the final valuation discussed by Sithole, that same stake was worth roughly R1 billion, turning the transaction into one in which the PIC had to pay out more than R400 million after taking over the shares.

And that is why the valuation of Lanseria sits at the centre of understanding how an unpaid PIC-funded loan ultimately resulted in the PIC itself making a substantial additional payment.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.