The Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (OUTA) has launched an urgent High Court application to stop the rollout of Phase 2 of the Administrative Adjudication of Road Traffic Offences (AARTO) system.
The AARTO system aims to remove traffic offences from the courts and handle them administratively, coupled with the introduction of a demerit system.
Speaking to CapeTalk/702's Africa Melane, OUTA Executive Director of Accountability, Advocate Stephanie Fick, said the legal challenge focused on how the system had been implemented, rather than whether AARTO was constitutional.
"It is about the ability to implement AARTO. It's less about whether we agree with whether AARTO is constitutional; that fight we already lost in the Constitutional Court. This is about the practical implementation of AARTO."
Fick said OUTA believes AARTO was introduced without two key requirements being in place: an Appeals Tribunal and proper public participation in the regulations.
She said motorists were left without any mechanism to challenge decisions because the Appeals Tribunal was not yet operational.
"One of those rights as a motorist you have is to approach the Appeals Tribunal. Now, you can imagine that if there's no appeals tribunal in this process, there's a vital flaw in this administrative process. So, how can you implement the system if a very important part is non-existent?"
OUTA heads to court to stop AARTO Phase 2 rollout
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
ALSO READ:
OUTA raises red flags over R1.2bn AARTO outsourcing deal
SA far from ready to implement AARTO Act, says OUTA
SALGA to keep fighting further rollout of new traffic fine system after court challenge dismissed
Fick also slammed the government for only publishing the regulations a day before Phase 2 came into effect, saying the public had been denied an opportunity to comment.
"Previously, the regulations were out for public participation, and I can tell you that it was problematic. There were a lot of spelling mistakes, there were a lot of practical problems, and there were a lot of questions. Now this time around, they literally published the regulations the day before the Act came into play for 62 municipalities."
Fick said motorists should not bear the consequences of poor planning.
"Government must get its house in order. The fact that they are unable to get this right is not the fault of motorists."
OUTA hopes to have the urgent application heard in the first week of August.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.