For nearly a decade, South Africa's Competition Commission has pursued some of the world's biggest banks over allegations that they manipulated the value of the Rand.

The case has wound its way through multiple courts before reaching the Constitutional Court, which delivered its long-awaited judgment at the end of June.

So, what was the case about, who remains implicated, and why should South Africans care?

Here is Eyewitness News' comprehensive explanation of the phenomenon:

THE STORY DATES BACK TO THE PERIOD BETWEEN 2007 AND 2013

The Competition Commission alleges that currency traders at around 28 local and international banks secretly communicated through private online chatrooms to coordinate trading in the US Dollar-Rand market.

The banks named included local institutions such as Standard Bank, Nedbank and FirstRand, alongside global banking giants such as JPMorgan, Citibank and HSBC.

According to the Commission, traders shared confidential client information, coordinated the prices they quoted customers and timed trades to influence the rand in ways that benefited the banks.

If proven, those actions would amount to market manipulation.

And because the rand influences the price of imports, fuel, food and other everyday goods, the Commission argued that the alleged conduct affected the broader South African economy and not just financial markets.

The Commission began investigating the allegations in 2015 before referring the matter to the Competition Tribunal in 2017.

It sought hefty administrative penalties of up to ten percent of each bank's South African turnover.

Some banks chose to settle.

Citibank paid a R69.5 million fine in 2017.

Standard Chartered later settled for R42.7 million in 2023.

Absa and Barclays also cooperated with investigators and received leniency.

Most of the remaining banks, however, challenged the case, setting off years of legal battles.

For almost a decade, the courts hardly dealt with whether the rand was actually manipulated.
Instead, the legal fight focused on technical questions.

Did South African competition law apply to foreign banks with little or no local presence?

Did the Commission provide enough evidence against each bank individually?

And were some banks lawfully included in the case at all?

Those procedural disputes moved between the Competition Tribunal, the Competition Appeal Court and eventually the Constitutional Court.

On 30 June, the Constitutional Court delivered a unanimous judgment.

The outcome was mixed.

The court found there was insufficient bank-specific evidence to support the allegation of one broad conspiracy involving South Africa's major banks.

This meant Standard Bank, Nedbank and FirstRand were cleared.

In Standard Bank's case, the court criticised the Commission, saying it had incorrectly identified one employee as a trader involved in the alleged scheme when he was in fact a salesperson.

Several international banks were also removed from the case, including Bank of America, Commerzbank, Nomura, Macquarie and Credit Suisse Securities.

THE MATTER IS FAR FROM OVER

The Commission succeeded in keeping claims alive against JPMorgan Chase Bank and Standard Americas Incorporated.

Separate rulings also mean HSBC Bank plc, BNP Paribas and Investec will still face proceedings before the Competition Tribunal.

For the first time in nearly 10 years, the case will now move beyond procedural arguments to examine the actual allegations.

The judgment has also sparked debate about the Competition Commission's investigative standards.

Critics argue the regulator failed to gather enough evidence before accusing some of the country's largest financial institutions.

Others point out that proving currency manipulation is extremely difficult.

Banks trade currencies every day, making it challenging to distinguish legitimate market activity from illegal coordination.

SURVIVING CASES WILL RETURN TO COMPETITION TRIBUNAL

The tribunal will hear the evidence against JPMorgan, Standard Americas, HSBC, BNP Paribas and Investec, and decide whether any of them manipulated the rand.

After nearly a decade of legal wrangling, South Africans may finally get answers to the question that started it all.

Was the rand deliberately manipulated, or did the Competition Commission overreach in one of the biggest competition cases in the country's history?

Whatever the outcome, the Constitutional Court's judgment has already set a higher standard for how major competition cases will need to be investigated and prosecuted in future.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.