The Financial and Fiscal Commission (FFC) has taken a dim view of National Treasury withholding funding to municipalities for financial breaches, questioning whether this is in line with the intention of the Constitution.

Treasury cracked the whip on financial mismanagement this week announcing that 69 municipalities, including the City of Johannesburg, would not be receiving their quarterly equitable share this month.

But the financial watchdog, the FFC, that advises government and Parliament on financial matters said that this power can’t go unchecked and Parliament has a duty to scrutinise the fairness of the decision within 30 days.

The FFC said that Treasury making the announcement to withhold funds from municipalities until they get their house in order, is not an absolute power.

It’s reminding Parliament that it has a binding obligation under sections 38 and 39 of the Municipal Finance Management Act to subject the Treasury’s decision to scrutiny within 30 days.

It said that these safeguards apply irrespective of whether the measure is described as the withholding or stopping of funds.

“The stopping of the allocation has serious budget pressures for citizens within the affected municipalities: infrastructure, electricity, water and sanitation and community services. The action must be a lawful condition on funding in terms of the Constitution, rather than an unlawful refusal to monitor funds already appropriated.”

The Commission said that Parliament should also request a report from the Auditor-General on the affected municipalities before it approves or renews the decision.

The FFC said that every municipality should be given the opportunity to answer allegations against it before any allocation continues to be withheld.

“A decision of this magnitude, affecting 69 municipalities and billions of rand in constitutionally guaranteed allocations to communities that depend on them for water, electricity, sanitation and basic services, cannot be allowed to take effect by executive action alone,” said the commission.

The Commission said that Parliament should also satisfy itself that the stoppage of funds does not exceed the limits set by law, and is not extended beyond what the Constitution permits.

Parliament is in recess until next month.