The controversy sparked by former DA leader John Steenhuisen's revelations about the lobbying of DA ministers by a public relations firm run by the party's founding leader Tony Leon has thrust the practice into the spotlight, igniting a debate about ethics, legality and even corruption.
Some argue that because lobbying is not regulated by legislation in South Africa, unlike in countries such as the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia and several European states, the practice is problematic in the local context.
But the chairperson of the South African Lobbying Association (SALA), Abdul Waheed Patel, disagrees.
SALA is the official body representing the ethical and transparent government and public affairs industry.
Patel believes there are adequate safeguards in place to ensure lobbying does not cross ethical boundaries.
He highlighted South Africa's extensive legal framework, including anti-corruption, procurement and public service transparency laws, which already regulate conduct in this area.
Patel describes ethical, professional lobbying as the organised representation of legitimate interests before public decision-makers and institutions, carried out in accordance with established processes, procedures and protocols.
ALSO READ: Tshwane DA dismisses allegations of ‘lobbying’ by former leader Tony Leon
Solly Msimanga denies lobbying claims involving Tony Leon's firm
However, the director of the University of Johannesburg's Centre for Public Policy and African Studies, Busani Ngcaweni, believes lobbying should be regulated to prevent unethical practices.
He says this should start within political parties themselves.
For example, while open lobbying is prohibited in the ANC, resources are still used to lobby and campaign for political positions.
"South African political parties must accept the fact that people do lobby and stop pretending they don't. People say they're not available for a position, while knowing full well that T-shirts are already being printed with their names on them. What happens within political parties ultimately influences what happens when those same people occupy positions in the state," said Ngcaweni.
What is lobbying?
In a constitutional democracy such as South Africa, where government decisions affect the lives of ordinary people, businesses, workers and the broader economy every day, Patel argues that those affected have both the right and the responsibility to present their views, evidence, expertise and lived experiences before those decisions are made.
"This type of participatory democracy, through advocacy and lobbying as one form of participation, is an important feature of democratic governance. Ethical, professional lobbying enables structured and transparent participation," said Patel.
He believes lobbying can strengthen democracy rather than weaken it.
"It helps decision-makers understand the practical implications of their decisions, identify potential pitfalls and unintended consequences, and consider alternative policy, legislative and regulatory options."
Patel pointed out that engagement between government and a range of stakeholders already takes place through established institutional processes. Ministers, government departments, senior officials, parliamentary committees and regulatory bodies all operate within constitutional and statutory frameworks governing how the public and non-state actors engage with decision-making processes.
"I want to be very clear that lobbying is not the problem; motive and human judgment are. The goal should be to build a system where advocacy remains open, transparent, ethical and accessible to anyone who wishes to engage with public institutions and decision-makers on a level playing field," he said.
Ngcaweni says it would be naïve to believe politicians are not themselves lobbying to advance their own interests or viewpoints.
He argues that public institutions can then become platforms for promoting those views, regardless of official government policy.
Ngcaweni believes regulation becomes especially important where large corporations and significant financial interests are involved.
"We have to regulate because companies spend substantial resources marketing their products and building relationships. Lobbying forms part of that broader strategy."
When the lobbying lines blur
In the Resolve Communications matter, Ngcaweni criticised former DA leader Tony Leon for allegedly using his political influence to lobby ministers from his own party.
He says this undermines public trust and ethical standards.
Patel, however, declined to comment directly on the controversy that has brought lobbying into the spotlight.
Leon’s firm is not a member of SALA.
Patel said the appropriate institutions are best placed to determine whether ethical standards or obligations associated with public office have been breached.
"It would be unfair to draw conclusions or cast aspersions on an entire profession based on one particular case."
Ngcaweni, however, argues that Leon's situation differs from that of other lobbyists.
"He's not lobbying in general terms. He's lobbying members of a political party where, for all intents and purposes, he is treated as the elder statesman. People listen to him and respect his authority. He's not lobbying his peers; he's lobbying people who are junior to him. That creates a very different dynamic."
Ngcaweni believes Leon has lost the moral authority to define what ethical public affairs lobbying should look like.
He says Steenhuisen's remarks have raised suspicions that Leon may have attempted to exert undue influence over ministers on behalf of his clients.
"Leon was not doing this out of goodwill. He runs a lobbying business. He invoices clients and would have benefited financially if those efforts were successful."
Is legislation necessary?
The Resolve Communications matter, now the subject of significant public debate and at least one complaint to the Public Protector by ActionSA, has reignited questions about whether South Africa should introduce legislation to regulate lobbying.
Patel believes no single law can eliminate unethical conduct in either the public or private sector.
"Laws establish standards and consequences, but professional ethics, institutional integrity and organisational culture are equally important drivers of ethical behaviour."
Patel says SALA places significant emphasis on its professional code of conduct alongside South Africa's existing legal and constitutional framework.
He notes that many professions already have codes of conduct that hold members accountable to ethical standards.
Patel believes self-regulation plays an important role, particularly when those standards exceed minimum legal requirements.
"There is always room to improve transparency. Greater transparency should strengthen democratic participation rather than create unnecessary barriers to legitimate engagement. The objective must be to build public trust and confidence in institutions without discouraging lawful participation in policymaking."
He cautioned against simply importing another country's lobbying model, saying any future legislation should reflect South Africa's own constitutional framework and traditions of participatory democracy.
Ngcaweni believes companies should regulate lobbying through formal policies overseen by their boards' social and ethics committees.
"When a company appoints me as its lobbyist, the parameters of that relationship must be clearly defined. There has to be accountability."
He added that clients should also clearly define what they expect from lobbyists and where the ethical boundaries lie.
Patel says, ultimately, ethical lobbying should never replace democratic decision-making but should instead improve the quality of information available to decision-makers.
"That is what strengthens democracy by ensuring a diversity of views and voices are heard, not just those with political access or proximity to power."