The City of Joburg has successfully fought off AfriForum's attempt to urgently stop the implementation of its increased water demand management levy, with the Johannesburg High Court finding that the rights group failed to make out a case for urgency.
Central to the city's argument on Tuesday was that AfriForum had known since 27 May, when the municipal budget was adopted, that the levy would take effect on 1 July.
ALSO READ:
AfriForum’s urgent water rate bid against City of Joburg could face postponement
Court to hear AfriForum’s bid to review City of Joburg’s 65.6% water rate hike
The city argued that AfriForum had more than enough time to challenge the decision but waited until days before its implementation to approach the court.
AfriForum brought the application to compel the city to stop collecting the controversial charge, arguing that it is unlawful, unconstitutional and places an unfair burden on residents.
Arguing for the city, Advocate Nathi Sithole said the matter was not about access to water but a budget issue.
“This matter has nothing to do with water. It has to do with a charge… it has nothing to do with the services of water. It has to do with the budgetary concerns and the collection of revenue in providing the services of water.”
Sithole further told the court the levy AfriForum sought to suspend was not a new charge but an existing levy that had long formed part of the city's water tariff structure.
“A party, which has been aware that there is a levy, called the water demand management levy, built by this City of Johannesburg, past almost six years, does nothing. They know about this thing, but today they're saying it is unlawful.”
Johannesburg residents will now pay a 67% higher water demand management levy from 1 July.
The water demand management levy is a fixed monthly charge imposed on both conventional and prepaid water connections, despite the amount of water a household uses. It is set to increase from R65 to about R124, including VAT.
Delivering judgment on Tuesday, Judge Cassim Moosa found that AfriForum had failed to demonstrate that implementing the levy would cause irreparable harm to residents.
AfriForum’s Marais de Vaal said he is disappointed by the outcome and maintains that the city has yet to explain the basis for the steep increase.
“We're not going to be able to be back in court before the end of the year, or towards the end of the year. So, it seems, at least a couple of months is going to pass before we know why this levy is what it is, this increase, and by that time, it might be too late to make another determination.”