The Western Cape High Court will hear final arguments on Thursday in a legal battle between Cape Union Mart and the Palestinian Solidarity Campaign (PSC) related to protests outside the retailer’s stores.

On Wednesday, lawyers for the PSC argued that the retailer failed to meet the legal requirements for a final interdict.

ALSO READ:

PSC vs Cape Union Mart: Protesters rally outside court

Cape Union Mart seeks court interdict to stop PSC protests

The applicants argued that Cape Union Mart and its chairperson, Philip Krawitz, have been subjected to sustained defamatory statements and falsely accused of funding genocide in Israel.

The PSC’s lawyer, Advocate Ismail Jamie, told the court that slogans used during the protests in question amount to protected political speech and hyperbole, not defamation.

Jamie said the interdict, if granted, will silence lawful protest, adding there's no evidence the PSC caused harm for the court to grant a final interdict.

"This is a classic gagging order."

Lawyers for the retailer argued that Krawitz is falsely accused of funding genocide in Israel, which has harmed his reputation and dignity.

JOURNALIST ALLEGEDLY ASSAULTED

Tensions flared outside the Western Cape High Court as supporters on opposing sides clashed during proceedings in the Cape Union Mart case.

Protesters linked to the PSC gathered outside the court, while supporters of the retailer and Krawitz held a counterdemonstration.

Police kept a close watch as groups traded slogans over the Gaza war, mirroring the legal battle playing out inside the court.

During the fracas, Muslim Views photojournalist Anwar Omar was allegedly assaulted by Bafana Modise, the spokesperson for South African Friends of Israel, who gathered outside the court to support Cape Union Mart.

Omar said he has since lodged a criminal complaint against Modise.

“He eventually hit me in my face with his fist and my camera against my face, and caused an injury above my right eye. I'm not sure yet how bad it is. I'm on my way to the doctor."