A farming industry group has welcomed renewed scrutiny of South Africa’s response to the foot-and-mouth disease outbreak, saying farmers have been “totally failed” by the government’s strategy and leadership.

The criticism comes after newly elected Democratic Alliance (DA) leader Geordin Hill-Lewis requested changes to the party’s representation in the Government of National Unity (GNU), including the removal of Agriculture Minister John Steenhuisen from the portfolio.

Hill-Lewis has described the move as part of a performance review of the DA’s team in government.

But the request has also renewed focus on the government's handling of the foot-and-mouth disease outbreak, which has had major consequences for farmers and the broader agricultural sector.

RELATED: Former DA leader Steenhuisen becomes first casualty of Hill-Lewis’ Cabinet reshuffle

Farming sector reacts to proposed change at Ministry of Agriculture portfolio

Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype

Farmers say policy, not personalities, is the real issue

Southern African Agri Initiative CEO Francois Rossouw said the focus should not be on whether Steenhuisen remains in office but on whether the government has the right strategy to combat the disease.

“For us, it's not whether the minister is removed or not. It's whether we've got a correct policy in place to help us fight foot-and-mouth disease.”

RELATED: FF Plus welcomes Steenhuisen’s removal as Agriculture Minister

Rossouw said the current policy direction, leadership approach and people advising the minister had failed to get the outbreak under control.

“We are so far behind that we would have to start from scratch again with this new administration.”

Disputed email fuels tensions

One of the flashpoints in the dispute involved an email exchange between farming stakeholders and the Department of Agriculture.

According to Rossouw, farmers and private sector stakeholders had sought a meeting with the minister to discuss a vaccination strategy.

He alleged that the minister’s chief of staff forwarded the email to senior departmental officials and included comments that farmers interpreted as dismissive.

“She forwarded the email, and unfortunately, she cc’d in one of the farming representatives... and told the director-general and the deputy director-general, ‘Please see attached for your amusement’.”

Rossouw said the incident reflected what he described as a broader unwillingness to engage with farmers during the crisis.

“That was just a wonderful summation of their whole approach to this foot-and-mouth disease crisis, which was to rather laugh at farmers than listen to them.”

He also referred to a separate incident in which he claimed strong language had been directed at organisations involved in legal action against the department.

Billions of rand at stake

Rossouw said the outbreak was already having severe financial consequences.

In the dairy sector, he estimated losses of between R5,000 and R6,000 per cow.

Across the wider red meat industry, he said, damages could eventually amount to between R10 billion and R80 billion.

“We haven't even started to calculate the full scope of damages.”

He argued that vaccination efforts had fallen far short of what was required.

According to Rossouw, only about 32% to 34% of the national herd had been vaccinated over six months.

“You need to vaccinate the whole national herd in between 60 and 90 days, and then you need to vaccinate them again.”

He said the number of vaccines purchased was less important than the number of animals successfully vaccinated.

“If we look at that number, we've totally failed farmers.”

Questions over private-sector involvement

A major point of contention has been the government's reluctance to allow wider private-sector participation in vaccination efforts.

Rossouw said industry groups remained puzzled by the approach.

“We still don't know why.”

He said countries that had successfully controlled outbreaks had relied heavily on private-sector support and farmer participation.

He pointed to Uganda as an example, claiming it had vaccinated millions of cattle by allowing farmers to vaccinate their own animals.

“We still don't know why, in the face of all the scrutiny, in the face of everybody opposing his strategy of state centralisation, he's persisted with the strategy.”

‘A hard fail’

Asked to assess Steenhuisen’s performance as agriculture minister, Rossouw delivered a blunt verdict.

“You would get a hard fail even on the new education standards.”

When pressed for a score out of 10, he replied: “It would be a two.”

Rossouw warned that South Africa remained far from containing the outbreak.

He compared the crisis to a fire that first needed to be stopped before it could be contained.

The challenge extends beyond cattle, he said, with sheep, pigs, and the game industry also affected.

“We have not even started to discuss the nitty-gritties around the disease and how to combat it for the next decade.”

Rossouw estimated that South Africa was only “about 10% to 15% in” on understanding and containing the full implications of the outbreak.

As questions continue over Steenhuisen’s future in Cabinet, the handling of foot-and-mouth disease is likely to remain a central issue for farmers, agricultural organisations and government alike.