Debate over what qualifies as a “fit and proper” person to serve on Parliament’s impeachment committee has dominated discussions on revised Section 89 rules.
The Democratic Alliance (DA) has been pushing for the inclusion of the criteria, saying MPs who serve on this all-important committee to investigate whether President Cyril Ramaphosa should be impeached should be beyond reproach.
But the MK Party and the EFF believe more work is required to determine a suitable definition for Parliament, as to who constitutes a fit and proper MP.
At the heart of the issue is whether the MK Party’s parliamentary leader, John Hlophe, an impeached judge, should serve on the Impeachment Committee.
The DA's George Michalakis said this committee can’t be considered the same as other Parliamentary committees, and the reputation of those tasked with deciding whether the President has committed impeachable offences should not be called into question.
ALSO READ:
Tempers flare in Parliament as ANC and MK Party clash over Ramaphosa impeachment rules
Committee considers rules on President Ramaphosa's Section 89 probe
Ramaphosa ‘won’t be distracted by narrow agendas’ over Phala Phala saga
"The definition of fit and proper is a matter of legal precedence, so the courts have already defined it."
Last year, the Western Cape High Court ruled that Hlophe was not fit and proper to represent Parliament on the Judicial Services Commission that interviews candidates to become judges.
The MK Party’s Mzwanele Manyi said while his party is not opposed to the principle, more work is needed to decide on a definition of “fit and proper”.
"What is this rush-rush for here? Let’s have the process properly rolled out."
The EFF's Natasha Ntlangwini agreed.
"You can’t just say they must be fit and proper. Fit and proper is determined by whom, and by what?"
EFF leader Julius Malema is also due to serve on the committee following his conviction on gun charges.
The ANC, DA and FF Plus have disagreed with Parliament’s legal advisors who have suggested that public input should be invited before introducing such a rule, since the Constitution does not make this limitation on who can serve as an MP.
The DA has already introduced a bill to amend the Constitution to prevent impeached individuals from becoming MPs.