The battle of disgraced Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge seeks to preserve his title and to safeguard his lifetime pension benefits. This is currently at stake as he faces impeachment following a sexual harassment scandal, which has played out for the nation to witness. In January 2025, the Judicial Conduct Tribunal (JCT) investigating the allegations against Mbenenge sat for its first hearings.
Retired Justice Bernard Ngoepe chaired the tribunal with the support of retired Judge Cynthia Pretorius and Advocate Gift Mashaba SC. This, after a complaint of sexual harassment was laid against the Eastern Cape Judge President by a secretary in the court, Andiswa Mengo.
KGOMOTSO MODISE EXPLAINS | The Mbenenge Tribunal
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
ALSO READ:
Judges Matter welcomes JSC finding Mbenenge guilty of misconduct
Mbenenge doesn't appreciate responsibility associated with his position: JSC
Judge Selby Mbenenge faces possible impeachment after JSC rejects tribunal findings
She claimed that between 2021 and 2022, Mbenenge sent her inappropriate messages and x-rated pictures that she claims were of him.
Mengo testified that she had tried to communicate her discomfort with the messages from the Mbenenge and had even attempted to find ways to tell him “no,” but he persisted.
Much of the argument advanced by her lawyers was that power dynamics were at play and cannot be ignored when considering Mengo’s responses, as Mbenenge is the most senior judge in the division.
This was in response to questions posed by the tribunal on why Mengo seemed to have been entertaining Mbenenge at certain points in their conversations.
Ultimately, the tribunal rejected the sexual harassment claim and did not find the judge president guilty of gross misconduct, but found that he contravened the Judicial Code of Conduct, a finding that Mbenenge is challenging in the high court.
But what seems to have prompted his bid in the Pretoria High Court is the decision by the Judicial Service Commission (JSC), which overturned the ruling of the tribunal.
Explainer: Tribunal probing allegations of misconduct against EC Judge President Mbenenge resumes
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
PRETORIA HIGH COURT BID
Judge Mbenenge’s high court case is in two parts. The first is his move to block his pending impeachment. Without getting an interdict by the court, nothing stops Parliament from beginning the impeachment process.
But Mbenenge believes the JSC and JCT got it wrong in their findings against him, and he is adamant that the courts will find in his favour.
The second part is the merits of his case. In his 86-page affidavit, he challenges the finding by the tribunal that he contravened article 5.1 of the judicial code, and he insists the JSC’s finding of gross misconduct was heavily dependent on that.
He claims the JSC’s finding was irrational, unprocedural and inconsistent with the principle of legality. Mbenege also claims that it is unprecedented for the JSC to overturn the JCT’s finding on misconduct.
The judge president has also highlighted a credibility finding made against Mengo by the tribunal.
The tribunal found that Mengo perjured herself during her testimony and lied when responding to certain questions.
Mbenenge said the JSC simply ignored this when making its finding against him, something that he insists is material. He also points out that Mengo had altered their WhatsApp conversations, deleting texts that did not suit her narrative.
WHAT HAPPENS NOW
Mbenenge has described the matter as semi-urgent, with the first part of the case, the interdict of his impeachment, having to be heard first. Cited among the respondents for this are both the JSC and JCT, the National Assembly, the Speaker of Parliament, President Cyril Ramaphosa and Andiswa Mengo.
The court would have to make a ruling on the interdict first, and that would be followed by the main case, where the merits would have to be explored.
This is likely to take months to play out in the courts before a final decision is made.