Independent Police Investigative Directorate's (IPID) Assistant Director of Investigations, Zelda Maphosho, has been accused of making up facts and illogical conclusions at the Madlanga Commission.

In 2021, Maphosho investigated a complaint by three law enforcement officials who opened a case with IPID after they were arrested on suspicion of trying to steal drugs from a crime scene.

ALSO READ:

IPID grilled over probe into arrest of cops accused of trying to steal drugs from crime scene

IPID investigator Zelda Maphosho takes the stand at Madlanga Commission over cocaine theft probe

Maphosho’s investigation found in favour of the complainants.

The incident refers to a drug bust in July 2021, where police confiscated a large consignment of cocaine with an estimated street value of about R300 million, in Aeroton, south of Johannesburg.

Crime analytics officer Marumo Magane was one of the first officers on the scene of the drug bust.

When Magane arrived on the scene, he called a National Intervention Unit member, Steve Phakula, to bring a sniffer dog.

Phakula is an officer based in Silverton in Pretoria.

Commission Chairperson Mbuyiseli Madlanga questioned IPID’s assistant director for investigations whether it was not suspicious that a police officer would travel all the way from Pretoria to work on a case in the south of Johannesburg.

ZM: Yes, it was suspicious, commissioner.”

MM: But you don’t seem to have acted on that suspicion

When Magane and Phakula appeared at the Madlanga Commission, they struggled to explain why they were at a drug bust scene, since that’s not part of their job descriptions.

In Maphoso's final report, she found the complainants were prevented from doing their work after they were arrested.

Maphosho said that if the complainants were not arrested, they would have had an opportunity to inspect two other containers suspected of carrying drugs.

However, co-commissioner Sesi Baloyi said that there is no one she interviewed who suggested there were three containers.

SB: “You keep speaking of 3-containers, can you just show us in the statement where anyone says there were 3-containers on that property that needed to be searched and we were prevented from searching, and I put it to you that nobody said that.”

ZM: “I agree, Commissioners, when I keep on referring to 3-containers, we don’t know whether the other containers were there the previous day or not, because the information we received was that 3-containers were given preference at the harbour, so we don’t know whether the 3-containers may have been driven from Durban straight to Scania, the previous day or not. Hence, we say the dog unit was going to search not only the container that was there but also the whole area.”

SB: “But you can't make up facts, you can't say ‘we don’t know whether’ and draw conclusions from that because you draw conclusions that they prevented the searching of the other containers. That’s a positive conclusion as it's based on the fact that there were 3-containers.”

Maphosho’s final report said that the people who arrested the complainants were guilty of defeating the ends of justice.