Suspended South African Police Service (SAPS) Organised Crime Unit member Fannie Nkosi's bail appeal has been denied by the Pretoria High Court.
Nkosi had challenged a lower court ruling refusing him bail, arguing that the legal provisions governing bail applications had not been properly applied and that his constitutional right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty had been infringed.
However, the High Court found that the magistrate correctly considered and applied the relevant bail legislation. Delivering the judgment, Judge Mokhine Mosopa said:
“I see no need to interfere with the judgment on bail as the magistrate did not exercise her discretion wrongly. This appeal ought not to succeed. I make the following order: the appeal against the Pretoria North Magistrate's Court's refusal to grant bail is hereby refused.”
The disgraced officer, suspected of being the middleman between alleged underworld boss Vusimuzi "Cat" Matlala and senior officers, faces an array of charges.
These include the unlawful possession of police dockets, explosives, firearms, ammunition, a stun grenade, defeating the ends of justice, and failure to safeguard firearms and ammunition.
ALSO READ: Fannie Nkosi’s legal team confident bail appeal will succeed
A central pillar of Nkosi's appeal was his contention that his right to be presumed innocent had effectively been taken away when Magistrate Thandi Theledi refused him bail. The Pretoria High Court rejected that argument, finding that the magistrate had expressly considered Nkosi's presumption of innocence, his personal circumstances, and his constitutional rights before denying bail.
Judge Mosopa noted that there was nothing in the lower court's judgment to suggest that Nkosi's right to be presumed innocent had been disregarded. The judge further found that a refusal of bail does not amount to a finding of guilt, but rather forms part of a judicial process aimed at determining whether an accused's release is in the interests of justice.
The state had argued that Nkosi's right to be released on bail was not absolute and had to be balanced against factors set out in the Criminal Procedure Act, including the risk of evading trial, interfering with witnesses, and undermining the administration of justice. Judge Mosopa agreed, finding that the magistrate had correctly weighed those considerations.
Nkosi, who declared that he earns R16,500 a month, was found with R52,000 in cash when he was arrested. Prior to that, during an earlier search and seizure, he was found with more than R300,000 that he could not explain.
The case will return to the Pretoria North Magistrate's Court on 16 July for further investigations.