A legal probe has dismissed an explanation given to Parliament by former Social Development Minister Sisisi Tolashe, who claimed it was merely a “clerical error” that she signed a five-year contract with the department’s former Director-General when Cabinet had only approved the appointment for a single year.

Presenting the findings of the forensic investigation to Parliament’s portfolio committee on Wednesday, law firm Mketsu and Associates said there appeared to have been deliberate administrative collusion in the final contract of the former Director-General, Peter Netshipale.

However, the African National Congress (ANC) continued to rally around Tolashe, with MPs questioning the credibility of the report because it did not include her side of the story.

Tolashe was fired as a minister last month following a slew of allegations against her, including irregular appointments within her personal office and the department. This includes the R2.2 million annual contract awarded to Netshipale.

Mketsu and Associates Managing Director Sydwell Mketsu has recommended disciplinary action against Netshipale, saying he must have known he was signing a contract that was not in line with the Cabinet directive. Netshipale has, however, since retired.

"The central findings are that the report rejects that this was a clerical error, finding evidence of a deliberate administrative process that rationalised and processed the irregular appointment."

Furthermore, Mketsu says two separate attempts to get Tolashe to explain her version of events, both in person and in writing, were ignored. As a result, no definitive findings could be made against her.

"Non-cooperation, restricted reports and witness removals were challenges that we experienced during our investigation."

The investigation also found that an official from the Department of Public Service and Administration appeared to be involved in the amended contract, but the scope of the probe was strictly limited to conduct within the Department of Social Development.