The Auditor-General’s office says that the City of Johannesburg was operating on “false assurances” about its entities, which have been receiving unqualified audits with findings for a number of years.
It said the municipality is thus not making decisions on credible information.
This includes the tabling of unfunded budgets which when exceeded, lead to irregular expenditure.
Having failed to table financial statements almost a year since the end of the 2024/25 financial year, the Auditor-General South Africa (AGSA) told Parliament's Standing Committee on Public Accounts (SCOPA) on Tuesday that this was due to the city challenging auditors on a number of findings.
The Auditor-General’s office said that despite interventions from National Treasury, the City of Johannesburg was showing little improvement in turning around its financial situation.
When considered on its own, the City of Johannesburg achieved a qualified audit, meaning auditors have expressed concerns about its financial statements.
However, in a consolidated set of financial statements that includes its trading and other entities, the city made the grade for an unqualified audit opinion with findings.
The Auditor-General’s chief auditor for Gauteng, Fhumulani Rabonda, said that municipal entities such as Johannesburg Water and City Power had been hovering in the unqualified audit status category for more than a decade, and were making little to no effort to achieve clean audit results.
"A culture that has got disregard for legislation, it’s a culture that’s actually breeding unscrupulous conduct and wastages."
Overall, the City of Johannesburg regressed in its audit outcome in the 2024/25 financial year.
Rabonda said that the municipality had failed to prevent unauthorised, irregular, and wasteful expenditure and management had been tardy to act against those responsible.
“We have expenditure that is recognised in the 2024/25 financial year, which belongs in previous years,” Rabonda said.
MPs said that they remained doubtful that the city could be considered a going concern, arguing that if it were a business, it would almost certainly have been declared bankrupt.