Landmark FMD ruling shifts power to farmers
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
The Southern African Agricultural Initiative (SAAI) has hailed a High Court ruling on private foot-and-mouth disease (FMD) vaccination as a major victory for livestock and game farmers.
The Gauteng High Court in Pretoria granted a landmark interim order that lawfully obtained FMD vaccines may be procured and administered privately, without State veterinary involvement.
RELATED:
- Steenhuisen gazettes new foot-and-mouth disease private vaccination scheme
- FMD crisis crushing livelihoods of SA communal farmers, says Meat Naturally Africa
The owners and managers of cloven-hooved livestock can now procure FMD vaccines from lawful importers, manufacturers, or their agents and administer them independently, subject to the conditions in the order, as Daily Maverick reports.
The order was granted in favour of SAAI, Sakeliga and Free State Agriculture.
It offers interim relief, pending a full review application to be filed within 20 days.
The judgment noted that the application was vehemently opposed by the first, second and third respondents - Agriculture Minister John Steenhuisen, Director General Mooketsa Ramasodi and the Director of Animal Health, Mpho Maja.
"After more than a year of the runaway spread of the state-controlled disease, it finally offers hope that the involvement and initiative of the private sector can provide the critical capacity to stop the disease (FMD)", SAAI said in a statement.
Stephen Grootes interviews Francois Rossouw, CEO of the agricultural interest group.
Rossouw maintains his claim that Minister Steenhuisen has been "lying" about the true state of FMD in the country, since the outbreak began eight months ago.
He says the Minister and Department's "obsession" with centralising vaccine control has slowed the fight against the disease.
"Finally we have a substantive judgment and court order, with that saying there was no impediment to farmers procuring vaccines or vaccinating their cattle, in law. The only impediment was the Minister himself."
"We're very pleased to get that judgment, but unfortunately it's been far too late because for the past eight months the disease has been running rampant... and because the Minister's been precluding the private sector from participating, no investment has been made and it's going to take a long time to reestablish those logistics supply lines."
Rossouw also accuses the government of hoarding the vaccine doses that are available, "which they've already gotten themselves".
Asked about the interim nature of the current court ruling, he explains that the application was made on an interim basis only because the applicants wanted to do it urgently.
"This was a crisis months ago; we're now picking up the bodies and losing farmers at an alarming rate. That is why we asked the court for an interim order, which says that within 20 days we have to prepare for the final order. Now, that date will be available maybe only at the end of 2026, or if we're lucky at the start of 2027, when the final application will be heard."
"I'm looking forward to that for the Department of Agriculture to deliver a record of what transpired over the past eight months because that's where the real damages claims will emanage from."
Scroll up to the audio player to hear more from the CEO of the Southern African Agricultural Initiative