The defence in the bail application of the man arrested in connection with the death of a witness who testified at the Madlanga Commission has accused the state of withholding critical information.

It argues murder accused Mathipandile Sotheni is being forced to fight a schedule 6 offence case “blindfolded” without access to the contents of the police investigation.

Sotheni has been applying to be released on bail at the Brakpan regional court after his arrest in March.

He is facing 16 charges including conspiracy to commit murder, murder and attempted murder which means this puts the burden on him to prove exceptional circumstances permit his release on bail.

ALSO READ:

State slams contradictions in Matipandile Sotheni’s bail bid over Witness D murder case

Alleged Witness D killer was not at the exact crime scene, court told

The state has alleged that he conspired with Wiandre Pretorius who later took his own life to kill Marius van der Merwe, also known as witness D.

During his testimony at the Madlanga commission, Witness D implicated members of the South African Police Serve (SAPS), Ekurhuleni Metro Police Department (EMPD) and private security operators including Pretorius in the murder and disposal of the body of Emmanuel Mbense.

During court proceedings Sotheni’s lawyer, advocate Nthabiseng Mohomane argued that forcing the accused to prove exceptional circumstances without access to the state’s investigation places a heavy burden on him, while the state insists he is not entitled to the contents of the docket at this stage.

Mohomane said the state failed to place sufficient evidence before court to justify his continued detention.

Adding his continued detention would result in severe hardship for family and financial prejudice to him personally including the possibility of losing his job.

According to submissions before the court, Sotheni has three children and also takes care of his sister's children and elderly parents.

Mohomane argued the accused’s personal circumstances, the weakness of the state’s case and the broader impact his incarceration would have on his family together constitute exceptional circumstances justifying bail.

She also maintained that strict bail conditions could address any concerns about him being a flight risk or his interference with the investigation.

While section 60(11)(a) of the Criminal Procedure Act requires an accused facing a schedule 6 offence to prove exceptional circumstances before bail can be granted, it does not define exactly what those exceptional circumstances are.

To bolster its case, the defence referred the court to the case of Katiso Molefe who was released on bail despite facing more than one count of conspiracy to commit murder and murder.

The state however contends, Sotheni has not shown exceptional reasons to be released and should remain behind bars until the end of the trial.