Civil society groups have raised concerns that South Africa’s revised White Paper on Citizenship, Immigration and Refugee Protection could deepen the exclusion of undocumented migrants and make access to healthcare more difficult.
The criticism comes after the Cabinet approved the latest version of the White Paper in March.
Groups representing migrants and healthcare activists argue the policy could entrench documentation checks and strengthen migration controls at a time when anti-immigrant sentiment is rising in South Africa.
RELATED: Panyaza Lesufi outlines plan to curb illegal settlements and fix Gauteng services
Who Gets to Belong? The Quiet Exclusion of Care in South Africa’s New Immigration White Paper
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
Concerns over healthcare access
Doctor Rebecca Walker from the African Centre for Migration and Society at Wits, speaking on behalf of Collective Voices for Health Access, said the revised White Paper could quietly exclude vulnerable people from healthcare services.
Walker said the policy merged the Immigration Act, the Refugees Act and the Citizenship Act into one system, creating what she described as a “radical overhaul” of South Africa’s immigration framework.
She warned that the document could harm the wider healthcare system, not only undocumented migrants.
“We are really worried about the kind of exclusion that's becoming entrenched through this White Paper at a time when anti migrant sentiments are becoming louder and louder,” said Walker.
What the law currently says
Walker said South Africa’s Constitution and the National Health Act currently allow everyone to access primary healthcare through public clinics, regardless of immigration status.
She said documentation was not required for access to basic healthcare services.
According to Walker, pregnant women, breastfeeding mothers and children under six are also entitled to free healthcare at all levels.
She rejected claims that undocumented migrants were responsible for pressure on public healthcare facilities.
“Diagnosing the cause of this as undocumented migrants is completely unsupported by evidence,” she said.
Fears over digital verification systems
Walker said the revised White Paper did not explicitly mention healthcare exclusion, but argued its proposals could still create barriers.
She pointed to plans linking civil registration systems, digital verification and stronger coordination between government departments.
Walker said these systems could effectively create “documentation checks at the door” of clinics and hospitals.
“The policy produces exclusion without explicitly stating it,” she said.
She also warned that undocumented migrants could become afraid to seek medical treatment if healthcare systems became more closely linked to immigration enforcement.
Calls for better documentation systems
Walker said improving access to legal documentation could help reduce tensions around immigration and access to public services.
She argued that many migrants were left undocumented because of failures within government systems.
Walker also noted that some South Africans struggled with documentation.
“Thirteen percent of South Africans do not have IDs,” she said.
She said improving documentation systems would help address broader problems affecting both migrants and South African citizens.