Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana has argued that his decision to increase the fuel levy is not a "like-for-like" replacement of the failed VAT increase from last year.

Godongwana maintains he is entitled to adjust the fuel levy as he sees fit and in the public interest, as stated in the Customs and Excise Act.

He was responding to submissions made by the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) in the Western Cape High Court, where the party is challenging the fuel levy increase, seeking to have it set aside and declared unconstitutional.

READ: EFF back in the Western Cape High Court to challenge fuel levy hike

The EFF’s counsel, Advocate Mfesana Ka Siboto, argued before the court that the Customs and Excise Act is wrong to allow the Finance Minister the authority to amend or increase the levy unilaterally.

Ka Siboto also submitted that the fuel levy increase announced by Minister Godongwana during his February budget was intended to compensate for the failed VAT increase last year.

However, Advocate Kameel Premhid, representing Godongwana, said this is not the case. He noted that the fuel levy, unlike the VAT increase, would have generated significantly less revenue.

"It seems like a pretty silly thing for the Minister of Finance to have done if he was using the fuel levy to increase taxes. He still had about R57 billion black hole in the budget. That demonstrates why this argument made on the level of generality and abstraction that the fuel levy increase is a like-for-like replacement is not supported by the facts."

The court has reserved judgment and will communicate its decision at a later date.