Parliament’s public participation processes are once again under scrutiny in the Constitutional Court, as the Western Cape government and the City of Cape Town challenge the hasty passing of the Public Procurement Act in 2024.
The Act, which will bring all procurement within the state under a central office housed in the National Treasury, also sets guidelines for preferential procurement in accordance with the government’s Broad-based black economic empowerment policies.
But Western Cape Premier Alan Winde has argued in the apex court on Monday that Parliament did not extensively consider all the input made on the bill, especially after amendments were made by the National Council of Provinces in 2023.
As the term of the sixth administration was ending, the Public Procurement Bill was one of those the former ANC-majority government sought to get over the line just weeks before the 2024 elections.
Through the establishment of a Public Procurement office located in the National Treasury, the bill aims to minimise corruption and improve service delivery in provinces and municipalities.
But Winde argued in court that Parliament’s Standing Committee on Finance did not consider all submissions made to it on the bill - and failed to conduct another round of public participation after material changes had been made by the National Council of Provinces to the chapter on preferential procurement.
Advocate Andrew Breitenbach, on behalf of the provincial government, said that by its own admission, Treasury failed to properly consider all the input received on the bill.
"The objective evidence shows that the Treasury, which briefed the Standing Committee on Finance on the written comments received, didn’t have the time to consider 67.4% of them. That being the case, how could the Treasury know that it responded to the primary stakeholders”?
Breitenbach told the court that it’s not too late to declare the Act unconstitutional and to set it aside, as it’s yet to come into full operation.