The South African Police Service (SAPS) has faced a scathing grilling from Members of Parliament for clearing police officers implicated in unlawful conduct during the Phala Phala investigation.
Members of the Police Committee raised their dissatisfaction over what they described as a culture of impunity within the police’s top management after those found guilty by the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) were later exonerated by the police.
Police watchdog IPID had recommended disciplinary action against Major General Wally Rhoode and others for violating SAPS regulations and the SAPS Act, but they were subsequently found not guilty by the police internal processes.
The IPID report, which was declassified in April, found that Major General Wally Rhoode, head of the Presidential Protection Service, acted unlawfully by conducting an unsanctioned investigation into the 2020 Phala Phala farm theft.
ALSO READ:
GNU coalition partners back Phala Phala impeachment inquiry against Ramaphosa
Phala Phala report review: Ramaphosa not interrupting Parliament’s process – Presidency
Some parties insist Parly must continue establishing Ramaphosa impeachment committee
The report concluded that Rhoode failed to report the crime in a proper manner and also misused state resources.
Committee member Dereleen James questioned how Rhoode was cleared by the police despite the evidence confirming wrongdoing.
"I also want to know why it is that SAPS found Rhoode not guilty, yet you have a President having to inform Presidential Protection of a break-in at his residence. In my mind, this should have been the other way around," James said.
Despite the criticism, Police Head of HR General Lineo Nkhuoa stated that all recommendations were complied with. She clarified that while IPID recommended that steps must be instituted against employees, the initiation of those steps constituted compliance, regardless of the eventual verdict.
General Nkhuoa added that all recommendations made by the Public Protector were also followed, including the requirement to take disciplinary steps against the implicated employees.