The fate of Cyril Ramaphosa’s presidency has returned to Parliament, which must now begin its work following a Constitutional Court order that the Phala Phala report be subjected to an impeachment inquiry.

The apex court handed down its highly anticipated judgment more than 500 days after the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) and the African Transformation Movement (ATM) approached the Constitutional Court.

The order, read by Chief Justice Mandisa Maya, found that Rule 129I of the National Assembly is unconstitutional and must be reviewed.

This is the rule Parliament relied on when it voted against adopting the independent panel’s report. The court also declared that vote invalid and unconstitutional, and ordered that the report be referred to an impeachment committee established in terms of the National Assembly’s rules.

This means Ramaphosa’s future will once again rest in the hands of parliamentarians, as the Speaker must now initiate the process to constitute the impeachment committee.

It is also the Speaker of Parliament who must determine the timeframes to enable the impeachment committee to finalise its work effectively.

The work of the impeachment committee

The committee will comprise Members of Parliament, with political parties proportionally represented. The current composition of Parliament means the ANC will not hold a majority.

The committee must continue from where the independent panel left off by holding hearings, during which all parties involved, including the president, must be afforded the right to be heard.

Once it has completed its work, the committee must submit a report to the National Assembly. While the committee will make findings and recommendations, these are not binding. The National Assembly will then vote based on those findings.

Rule 129I amendment

In December 2022, the ANC used its majority to have the independent panel’s report set aside. It relied on Rule 129I, which allowed Parliament to vote on whether to adopt the report.

However, the court has now declared the rule inconsistent with the Constitution, invalid, and set it aside. It also proposed an amended version of the rule pending its formal amendment.



As a result, the vote Parliament took to reject the report has also been invalidated. The National Assembly will now use the revised rule to begin the tabling of the report before it is referred to the impeachment committee.

What can the president do?

President Cyril Ramaphosa is reportedly weighing his legal options, with a review of the independent panel’s report said to be under consideration.

In May 2023, Ramaphosa approached the Constitutional Court to review the report, but the court ruled that the application did not fall within its jurisdiction and that no case had been made for direct access.

The president subsequently abandoned the review application that had been headed to the High Court.

The EFF has since argued that if Ramaphosa plans to pursue a judicial review, it would amount to an attempt to frustrate and delay the parliamentary inquiry.

The party says it is prepared to legally challenge any move to review the report.

The EFF argues that such a review would demonstrate profound disrespect not only for Parliament, but also for the judiciary and the constitutional order itself.


The president could also resign, but the EFF says that would not absolve him from the parliamentary process.

Motions of no confidence

The uMkhonto weSizwe Party (MK Party) and the ATM have both launched motions of no confidence against the president following the Constitutional Court judgment.

Unlike an impeachment vote, which requires a two-thirds majority to remove the president from office, a motion of no confidence requires only 50% plus one vote to remove a sitting president.

The parties want the vote to be conducted by secret ballot, but the Speaker of the National Assembly must first determine whether the motions will proceed.

The timelines for the impeachment process will be determined by Speaker of Parliament Thoko Didiza ahead of a final vote in the National Assembly once the impeachment committee has completed its work.