Cape Town residents furious over the City of Cape Town’s controversial fixed tariff increases say they are being priced out of their homes, while Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis insists the city cannot stop investing billions into infrastructure upgrades.

The dispute over Cape Town’s tariff structure intensified after a full bench of the Western Cape High Court ruled that parts of the city’s tariff model were unlawful.

The ruling has triggered renewed outrage from property owners who argue that rising municipal charges, linked to soaring property values, are becoming impossible to afford.

Speaking on CapeTalk on Friday, Hill-Lewis defended the city’s infrastructure spending programme and warned that the court ruling could ultimately leave middle-class and lower-income households paying even more.

“The question only is how do we split those costs equitably across the city,” he said.

RELATED: 'Cape Town property rate hikes hitting pensioners and middle class hardest'

Right of reply: Cape Town mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis weighs on tariff ruling

Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype

Cape Town tariff battle sparks anger among homeowners

The fixed tariff fight has become one of the most contentious issues facing the City of Cape Town.

Residents have repeatedly complained that rapid property value growth in Cape Town is driving up municipal bills far beyond what ordinary households can sustain.

Ratepayers say their property values may have increased on paper, but their incomes have not kept pace with escalating municipal costs.

Hill-Lewis acknowledged the frustration.

“We do not want any person to feel as though they can no longer live in their home because of affordability.”

The mayor said the city attempted to soften the impact through pensioner rebates and indigent relief programmes.

Cape Town has consistently argued that wealthier property owners should contribute more towards infrastructure through a system of cross-subsidisation.

But the court ruled against using property values as the mechanism for determining certain fixed charges.

City warns court ruling could shift costs elsewhere

Hill-Lewis claimed the judgment could unintentionally shift more of the financial burden onto middle-class and lower-income residents.

He said the city was now scrambling to find another lawful mechanism for cross-subsidisation.

“This judgment effectively unwinds that cross-subsidisation,” he said.

The mayor warned that alternatives also carry complications.

He said charging based on property size would not work well in Cape Town because some of the city’s smallest properties, particularly in affluent coastal suburbs, are among the most valuable.

He also suggested that area-based tariffs could trigger fresh complaints from residents living on opposite sides of the same street but facing different charges.

“There’s no perfect system,” he said.

Cape Town infrastructure spending at centre of fight

At the heart of the dispute is the city’s rapidly expanding infrastructure budget.

Hill-Lewis confirmed that Cape Town’s capital budget had grown from roughly R4 billion to R13 billion.

He insisted the spending surge was essential to prevent infrastructure collapse.

The mayor pointed to major projects including sewer upgrades, wastewater treatment works, water infrastructure projects, road rehabilitation and the expansion of the MyCiTi bus service.

“If anything, I would love to be able to spend much more on pipe replacements, not less,” he said.

Hill-Lewis warned that reducing infrastructure investment would leave Cape Town facing the same failures experienced in other South African metros.

“We have far too many people living with sewer spills every day in their communities because our pipe system is under so much strain.”

Property owners say city is ignoring affordability crisis

Despite the city’s defence, anger among Cape Town property owners continues to grow.

Critics argue that residents are being forced to fund aggressive infrastructure expansion while battling rising living costs, utility increases and stagnant income growth.

Listeners during the radio discussion accused the city of behaving as though homeowners were an endless source of revenue.

Some argued that Cape Town residents are not opposed to infrastructure investment but believe the city must cut internal costs and improve efficiency before imposing further financial pressure on households.

Others called for more innovative funding mechanisms, including public-private partnerships, municipal bonds and greater support from the national government.

Hill-Lewis said the city was already pursuing external financing options, including loans from development finance institutions and municipal bonds traded on the JSE.

But he argued Cape Town still largely must fund infrastructure through its own revenue base.

“Our population has grown exponentially, and we’re still getting the same equitable share that we got in 2010,” he said.

Rising property prices adding pressure

Hill-Lewis also linked Cape Town’s escalating property values to semigration from other provinces.

He said thousands of people relocating to Cape Town from Gauteng and elsewhere had intensified pressure on the city’s property market.

“That is what has put pressure on our property market and has driven prices up because people want to live in the only place that works,” he said.

The mayor stressed that the city does not determine property values, arguing that market demand is driving increases.

Still, for many homeowners, rapidly rising property values are translating into sharply higher municipal costs.

That has fuelled fears among pensioners and middle-class families that they may eventually be forced to leave long-time homes because of mounting rates and fixed charges.

City searching for new tariff model

The City of Cape Town now faces the challenge of redesigning its tariff structure following the court ruling.

Hill-Lewis said officials were examining alternative systems that comply with the judgment while still allowing the city to maintain infrastructure investment.

He insisted the city was trying to find a model that remains “fair and as compassionate as possible”.

But with public frustration growing and affordability concerns intensifying, the battle over Cape Town’s fixed tariffs appears far from over.