The Public Service Commission (PSC) has recommended that Social Development Minister Sisisi Tolashe discipline her special advisor, Ngwako Kgatla, for his role in manipulating the CV of a relative to be employed as Tolashe’s private secretary.
While Lesedi Mabiletja resigned last year in the wake of the storm that erupted from her appointment, the PSC said efforts should also be made to recoup the salary that she was paid.
Presenting the findings of an investigation into the appointment to Parliament’s portfolio committee on Wednesday, PSC chairperson Somadoda Fikeni said it was an indictment on the department that a college graduate could be parachuted into such a senior role.
While several of those involved in the irregular appointment of Tolashe’s former private secretary have since resigned, Fikeni said the State should develop a register to report those who evade consequence management.
ALSO READ:
DA demands answers from Ramaphosa over Minister Tolashe’s double vehicle donation
ActionSA opens criminal case against Tolashe for failing to declare donation
Pressure mounts on Ramaphosa to act against Minister Tolashe as SUV scandal fuels public anger
The PSC said that ordinarily, Mabiletja should have been charged with fraud for lying about her competencies.
“This idea of people resigning when findings are imminent should not become an escape clause for accountability.”
Fikeni also delivered a scathing assessment of the Human Resources (HR) division within Tolashe’s department, with at least two officials implicated in the irregular appointment.
“Once the HR of a department is implicated, it often is an indication of a bigger problem, which is systemic.”
The PSC has reminded the committee that its recommendations are binding and that a new bill currently before Parliament will entrench this.
ANC MPS COME TO TOLASHE'S DEFENCE
While Fikeni sounded the alarm on what he called a “web of deceit” within the Social Development Department, African National Congress (ANC) members of Parliament (MPs) rallied to Tolashe’s defence, saying the findings were not evidence to make a judgment on her fitness to hold office.
For her part, Tolashe insisted she’s not misled Parliament about any of the controversies surrounding her, including the donation of vehicles to the ANC Women’s League that ended up with her children.
One by one, ANC MPs closed ranks around Tolashe with MP Stanley Ramaila saying it was not the parliamentary committee’s job to react to media reports or social media rumours.
“That is our role, to play oversight over the minister and the department. Not prosecution. And we must not conflate these things.”
Despite Fikeni indicating on at least two occasions that the findings into irregular appointments within the department was final, Ramaila and MP Thokozile Sokanyile insisted it was premature to draw any conclusions about Tolashe’s conduct, until she had responded to the report.
“We know nowadays, social media can make a person [appear] incapacitated to lead a department.”
Meanwhile, another ANC MP, Kerileng Thlong, dismissed claims that Tolashe and her daughter had mistreated a housekeeping staffer.
“I think this thing is just rumours of the food aide, because if it was a serious case, it could have long been reported.”
ANC MPs also said it was not the committee’s place to probe the controversial vehicle donation, and it should rather be left to Parliament’s Ethics Committee.
Tolashe has until next week to respond to the PSC on its findings.