The Constitutional Court (ConCourt) will on Tuesday hear two combined applications by the Board of Healthcare Funders and the Western Cape government seeking to have the National Health Insurance (NHI) Act declared unlawful.

The applicants are arguing that both houses of Parliament failed to comply with constitutional requirements for meaningful public participation before passing the NHI bill.

The National Assembly passed the bill in June 2023, and the National Council of Provinces (NCOP) confirmed it in December of the same year.

President Cyril Ramaphosa signed it into law in 2024, but its proclamation has been delayed pending the outcome of the ConCourt challenge.

The NHI Act seeks to fundamentally overhaul the country’s healthcare system, creating a single fund, the NHI fund, an autonomous body that will purchase healthcare services from public and private providers.

This will prevent private hospitals from setting their own fees for services provided by the NHI and limit the role of medical aid schemes.

RELATED: Parliament's public participation process over NHI Act to face scrutiny in ConCourt

At the heart of the case is whether Parliament’s process met constitutional requirements for public participation before passing the bill and whether the law should be set aside.

The applicants have argued that public participation was defective, citing four key points, including that despite submissions, some of which opposed provisions of the bill, there were no changes made.

In addition, they believe Parliament has not disclosed how the NHI will be funded, and that the outcome was predetermined.

However, Parliament will argue that the apex court lacks jurisdiction over the matter, saying the applicants have failed to plead a case that triggers its jurisdiction.

It said the arguments raised go to the substance of the legislation and not the process, adding that even if defects are found, the appropriate remedy is to return the act to Parliament for correction instead of setting it aside.

ALSO READ:

Access to details on decision to sign NHI Bill into law is a privilege, argues Ramaphosa

MPs question Motsoaledi spending R9 million to hire 12 counsel to defend NHI

Motsoaledi defends spending R9m on lawyers, says health dept being sued on several fronts over NHI

BHF confident it will be able to prove the NHI Act is unconstitutional